|
ALIAS BETTY
Devastated by the death
of her son, a novelist contemplates suicide until her loose-cannon
mother has the audacity to bring home a boy shes kidnapped
on the street.
CAST: Sandrine Kiberlain, Nicole Garcia, Mathilde
Seigner, Luck Mervil, Edouard Baer, Stephane Freiss, Roschdy Zem,
Alexis Chatrian, Arthur Setbon
DIRECTOR: Claude Miller
"Claude
Miller's finely layered screen adaptation of Ruth Rendell's novel
'Tree of Hands' is such an accomplished piece of filmmaking that
it interweaves enough characters and themes to fill three movies...Although
plenty of emotional fireworks detonate, 'Alias Betty' maintains
a chilly composure while following its volatile characters around...At
heart the movie is a deftly wrought suspense yarn whose richer shadings
work as coloring rather than substance...'Alias Betty' ultimately
rests on the slim shoulders of Ms. Kiberlain, whose Betty is deeply
touching without a hint of sentimentality." --Stephen Holden,
The New York Times
"In some respects, Mr. Miller's opus may seem too facile for
some tastes. Still, Ms. Khiberlain, Ms. Garcia and Ms. Seigner brilliantly
play the three mothers like a dissonant string trio on a single
theme: the varied agonies of motherhood...Still, I remain suspicious
of redemptive motherhood as a rebuke to 'extreme' feminism, and
of the treatment with kid gloves of the film's token African character.
It is all too easy." -- Andrew Sarris, The New York Observer
"Does all this turbulence end in violence, bloodshed and spiritual
renewal? Of course it does--this is a French film in the classic
passionate tradition. Director Claude Miller has performed a splendid
balancing act, teasing and entertaining us with his tall, emotionally
resonant tale. And it seems fitting that Kiberlain, Garcia and Seigner
shared the Best Actress Award at the Montreal World Film Festival.
They are a splendid trio, and Alias Betty is a genuine
beauty." --Guy Flatley, Moviecrazed
"Miller is known as a gifted
director of actresses, and the leading ladies here do not disappoint.
Betty, Margot, and Carole may represent radically different styles
of motherhood, but they're also sympathetic (even if batty or violent)
and marvelously vivid. Infusing Rendell's intrigue with warmth and
humor, Miller makes the film's sometimes mechanical and giddy narrative
into something grander--a meditation on maternity as a form of inspired
madness." -- Leslie Camhi, The Village Voice
"'Alias Betty' works as a decent urban thriller. And, on a
different level entirely, it's about just why right is right, wrong
is wrong, right might be wrong and wrong might be right. And what
it all implies about playing dice with the universe." -- John
Anderson, Newsday
"...Claude Miller takes that basic story and weaves it together
with stories about the kidnapped boy's mother and other characters
and comes up with a stylish thriller...Despite a contrived ending
that brings together all the film's characters, 'Alias Betty' is
inventive filmmaking." -- V.A. Musetto, The New York Post
|