|
8 MILE
An insolent, secretly sensitive
rapper must conquer his stage fright before he can show Detroit
and the rest of the world that he is an artistic genius.
CAST: Eminem , Kim Basinger, Mekhi Phifer, Brittany Murphy, Evan
Jones, Omar Benson Miller, Eugene Byrd, De'Angelo Wilson, Taryn
Manning, Michael Shannon, Chloe Greenfield, Anthony Mackie, Nashawn
Breedlove
DIRECTOR: Curtis Hanson
"As
a camera subject, Eminem is resistant material--he has the general
aspect of a walking hard-on--but he's fascinating, too, and his
way of withholding himself is both a natural reflex and a method
of teasing and dominating everyone else...Like the fighting in 'Rocky'
and the dancing in 'Saturday Night Fever,' the rap songs in '8 Mile'
possess a redemptive power. They release intolerable feelings of
disgust, the fear of remaining a loser forever...In the tradition
of 'Rocky' and 'Fever,' the movie is a shrewdly engineered piece
of proletarian pop--a story of triumph--but, like Eminem's enraged
lyrics, '8 Mile' has its own kind of vile candor...The movie says,
'Out of this junk, out of the self-hatred and anger that grow from
living amid junk, rappers will make their art.'" --David Denby,
The New Yorker
"Directed with superlative grace by Curtis Hanson from an uneven
script by Scott Silver, the film takes place in the Detroit slums...The
movie is positioned to be an anthem for finding one's true voice
and making the right choices in life. Luckily, that's not all it's
up to. What it's really about is the euphoria that talent can bring
to those who are possessed by it. That euphoria lights up the screen.
Eminem isn't a trained actor, but even when he's not in motion,
he never goes slack...Who could have predicted that a rap movie
starring Eminem would, at its best, be one of the year's sweetest
joyrides?" --Peter Rainer, New York
"O.K., so I'm the wrong audience for this teenage junk. To
me, rap is crap. Big news. And two hours of torture about the empty
posturing of a no-talent loser who dreams of becoming the next Tupac
Shakur does not fit my definition of upward mobility... I'm staying
home with Cole Porter and the Gershwins...it seems like a shameless
biopic about Eminem himself, but look closer and you'll detect a
warmed-over, recycled Rocky in a high-speed microwave...The thought
of Eminem as a movie star is horrible enough, but even if a lack
of better judgment sentences you to two hours of this punishment,
the sight of Eminem vomiting is not my idea of a 'Get Out of Jail
Free' card." --Rex Reed, The New York Observer
"... watching Curtis Hanson's gritty and electrifying '8 Mile,'
the first thing you notice about Eminem, the most scaldingly powerful
artist in pop music today, is how vulnerable he looks... It's hard
to tell, at a glance, if his jittery presence is a reflection of
all the anger he's got pent up inside or of how nervous he is about
letting it out...Eminem holds his aggression back, projecting the
scurrilous, soft-eyed yearning of a hip-hop James Dean...All of
the performers are terrific..." --Owen Gleiberman, Entertainment
Weekly
"The film's star, Eminem, doesn't appear to have a great deal
of range, but he can play himself. Even though the protagonist is
named Jimmy Smith, the thoughtful '8 Mile' is a raw version of the
rapper's own story...maybe the project doesn't make sense in the
abstract, but once you submit to it, it works." -- Elvis Mitchell,
The New York Times
"For the final 15 minutes, viewers have the electrifying experience
of watching Eminem do what he does best, improvising in a rap contest
that constantly ups the ante in creative insults, personal invective
and tribal provocation. But the payoff comes after an hour and a
half of a long, criminally tiresome setup
director Curtis Hanson
(who directed the overrated L.A. Confidential and the
underrated Wonder Boys) squanders the opportunity to
make the Raging Bull of rap movies. Instead he opts
for foursquare melodrama, taking viewers through the lumpenproletariat
squalor of Rabbit's home life, a disastrous love affair with a would-be
model (played by an authentically skanky-looking Brittany Murphy)
and the rapper's tendency to freeze up when he's in front of an
audience
For some reason Hanson has decided to make a rap movie
in which fists fly more often than words do." --Ann Hornaday,
The Washington Post
"What makes 8 Mile actually fascinating is its
depiction of a poor urban America in which issues of race have been
submerged by class and diluted by the total cultural triumph of
rap
Eminem is no Madonna: He's perfectly convincing within
a limited range, as you would expect from his performances in music
video and on record
Kim Basinger, sad to say, is woefully unconvincing
as trailer trash - her perfect Hollywood haircut doesn't help."
--Jonathan Foreman, The New York Post
There are a lot of staleand nefariousclichés
in 8 Mile, but most of the time they're overwhelmed
by the pulsing, grinding, hopped-up camerawork and the soulful star
turn of Eminem. This is basically a new-style boxing movie, only
the matches happen in a giant industrial warehouse in Detroit called
the Shelter, and the punches are the lyricsor, more accurately,
the rhyming insultsof the raps
Eminem has a good camera
faceat once soft and hard, woozy and defiant, like a punk
Robert Mitchum
At its best, the movie presents a universe in
which everyone raps for his or her dignity
The movie is at
its most retro whenever Brittany Murphy shows up in her red-leather
minis and fish-net stockings to tempt the hero away from the work
he must do. Murphy is a terrific actress: It will be a shame if
she becomes a star via this embarrassing siren turn." --David
Edelstein, Slate
|