TARNATION
****
CAST: Jonathan Caouette, Renee LeBlanc,
Rosemary Davis, Adolph Davis, David Sanin Paz, Michael Cox
DIRECTOR: Jonathan Caouette
SCREENWRITER: Jonathan Caouette
Scanning
the credits for this movie, you might well ask who the hell is writer-director-star
Jonathan Caouette. But once you’ve seen “Tarnation,”
you’ll never have to ask again. Here’s why:
This 31-year-old, full-blown auteur draws us into a cruel,
heartbreaking, occasionally hilarious world inhabited by emotionally
maimed people, most of whom happen to be members of his own family.
As we observe them in shockingly naked encounters through the years,
we come to experience Jonathan Caouette, his mother and his grandparents
intimately, even though in the end they remain tantalizing mysteries.
How
is it that the filmmaker summoned not only total recall but also
the necessary visual tools to take us on this autobiographical odyssey?
The answer is deceptively simple. On his eleventh birthday, Jonathan
was given a super-8 camera, and from that day on, he obsessively
photographed every bizarre event--from major to minor--that took
place in his epically dysfunctional family and in the stifling Texas
suburb they more or less called home. And, as the bedroom shot above
suggests, he seldom left himself out of the picture.
“Tarnation” is an artfully structured montage of the
multitude of images he managed to capture with his trustworthy
super-8, a succession of extraordinarily raw and riveting
scenes, both in grainy black-and-white and in vivid, over-the-top
color. Sometimes they are narrated with unflinching candor by Caouette
himself, sometimes they are related by his three closest relatives
in voices tinged with unforgettable torment. At other times, plot
developments--such as instances of sexual abuse or attempts at suicide
by Jonathan, a yearning, emphatically gay youth left by his mentally
ill mother in the care of his monumentally inept grandparents--are
delivered by hand-scrawled titles, phrases and short, deadpan sentences.
The
good news for Caouette was that he
was able to make his incredibly ambitious film, which he edited
on a laptop computer, for considerably
under $1,000. Also falling into the category
of good news is the fact that he finally fled from the best
little madhouse in Texas to New York, where he moved in with David,
his sweet, thoroughly sane boyfriend (whose devotion to Jonathan
is touchingly demonstrated in “Tarnation”). But there
is little doubt that the true love of Jonathan’s life is his
mother, Renee LeBlanc (pictured with him at left). Once a child
model, Renee fell from the roof of her house when she was a young
woman, landed on the ground in a standing position, blacked out,
and woke up paralyzed in a hospital bed. She did recover physically--she
even married briefly, which explains Jonathan’s emergence
on the scene--but apparently not mentally. That’s why
her chronically addled parents decided to put her through a massive
series of shock treatments that led to major schizophrenia and numerous
excursions to the psychiatric ward.
Renee, both in her demented moments and her periods of lucidity
and loving, is an overwhelming, haunting presence in “Tarnation,”
and it’s a pleasure to report that she eventually joined Jonathan
in New York (and it’s clear that she looks upon David as a
second son). The bad news is that Jonathan did not show up for a
press conference when his film was recently shown at Manhattan’s
Lincoln Center. The reason given by New York Film Festival spokesman
Graham Leggat was “problems in the family.”
|