UNITED
93
Not all four of the planes hijacked by
terrorists on September 11, 2001 arrived at their intended destinations.
We are reminded of that fact in this harrowing docudrama by Paul
Greengrass.
CAST:
David Alan Basche, Richard Bekins, Susan Blommaert,
Ray Charleson, Christian Clemenson, Khalid Abdalla, Lewis Alsamari,
Ben Sliney, Major James Fox, Colonel Robert Marr
WRITER-DIRECTOR:
Paul Greengrass
“Greengrass’s
movie is tightly wrapped, minutely drawn, and, no matter how frightening,
superbly precise...‘United 93’ is a tremendous experience
of fear, bewilderment, and resolution...once the flight is aloft
Greengrass sticks to real time, and the passing minutes have an
almost demonic urgency. This is true existential filmmaking: there
is only the next instant, and the one after that, and what are you
going to do? Many films whip up tension with cunning and manipulation.
As far as possible, this movie plays it straight. A few people made
extraordinary use of those tormented minutes, and ‘United
93’ fully honors what was original and spontaneous and brave
in their refusal to go quietly.” --DAVID
DENBY, The New Yorker
“Even if someone, say, Paul Greengrass, can craft the ideal
representation of 9/11 (the most tasteful, the most meticulously
researched, the most ‘true’), what does it avail us
to watch the thing? I hope I don't sound like a cynic with a heart
of lead when I say that ‘United 93,’ as grueling as
it was to sit through, left me feeling curiously unmoved and even
slightly resentful. At some point, Greengrass' exquisite delicacy
and tact toward all sides—the surviving families, the baffled
air-traffic controllers, even the hijackers themselves—began
to smack of political pussyfooting...Why was this film made, and
why was it made now?... Greengrass maintains an almost maddening
neutrality—a neutrality that shades at times into what might
feel to some viewers like sympathy with the devil.” --DANA
STEVENS, Slate
“This is first-rate, visceral filmmaking, no question: taut,
watchful, free of false histrionics, as observant of the fear in
the young terrorists' eyes as the hysteria in the passenger cabin,
and smart enough to know this material doesn't need to be sensationalized
or sentimentalized...But without context, psychology, politics or
contemplative distance, you may wonder what, exactly, this re-creation
illuminates...On some basic level, it can't help but be a thrill
ride, albeit one that leaves you somber and drained. Whether you
need that ride is a question you'll have to answer yourself.”
--DAVID ANSEN, Newsweek
“This is a masterful and heartbreaking film, and it does honor
to the memory of the victims...the film doesn't depict the terrorists
as villains. It has no need to. Like everyone else in the movie
they are people of ordinary appearance, going about their business.
‘United 93’ is incomparably more powerful because it
depicts all of its characters as people trapped in an exorable progress
toward tragedy. The movie contains no politics. No theory. No personal
chit-chat. No patriotic speeches.” --ROGER
EBERT, Chicago Sun-Times
“This staggering, draining film is exceptionally accomplished
but extremely difficult to watch...It's a mark of Greengrass' unequaled
gift for believably re-creating reality that, once seen, it's impossible
to get ‘United 93’ out of your mind, no matter how much
you may want to...it is a film envisioned as a monument, a memorial
tribute, and in our hearts we want something more.” --KENNETH
TURAN, The Los Angeles Times
“A persuasively narrated, scrupulously tasteful re-creation
of the downing of the fourth and final plane hijacked by Islamist
terrorists on Sept. 11...it is good, in a temple-pounding, sensory-overloading
way that can provoke tears and a headache...But because Mr. Greengrass
treats everyone onboard as equals, and because he throws us into
the story without telling us who they are, they never become individuated...the
absence of any historical or political context raises the question
of why this particular movie was made. To jolt us out of complacency?
Remind us of those who died? Unite us, as even the film's title
seems to urge? Entertain us? To be honest, I haven't a clue...‘United
93’ inspires pity and terror, no doubt. But catharsis? I'm
still waiting for that.” --MANOHLA DARGIS,
The New York Times
“For me, Paul Greengrass' meticulously researched movie was
a deeply cathartic experience. It's a long, brutal and honest look
at a shattering event some Americans would apparently prefer not
to see depicted--but also a respectful, inspiring one that's in
no way exploitative or emotionally manipulative.” --LOU
LUMENICK, The New York Post
“No amount of research or faithfulness can obscure the fact
that this is a fictionalized reenactment of an epically painful
moment in our history. In the end, nobody really knows what happened
on Flight 93 or what ultimately brought it down 90 minutes after
it took off. Handled in the wrong way-- i.e., as a standard Hollywood
thriller--‘United 93’ could easily have inspired revulsion.
That isn't the case here. Although the film has been made with great
finesse, it is devoid of showbiz exploitation.” --PETER
RAINER, The Christian Science Monitor
“Pulling the bandage of sentiment cleanly away from oozing
concepts like ‘heroism' and ‘our nation's war on terror’
in the aftermath of recent wounds, here's a drama about the most
politically charged crisis of our time that grants the dignity of
autonomy to every soul involved...The final struggle takes only
a few minutes, but it feels like an eternity, a blur of action,
the deadly outcome of which cannot be changed by wishing it otherwise...Do
we benefit from recognizing, in ‘United 93,’ that there's
no difference between those who died and us, in fear and in courage?
Absolutely.” --LISA SCHWARZBAUM, Entertainment
Weekly
“Why anyone would want to revisit the dreadful day of Sept.
11, 2001, is beyond this particular critic. But those who find meaning
and catharsis by watching fetishistically accurate reenactments
on the big screen will be well rewarded by ‘United 93’...To
Greengrass’s credit, he avoids politics altogether, focusing
instead on the tick-tock of how reality slowly dawned on an improbably
gorgeous late summer morning. ‘United 93’ may be the
best movie I ever hated.” -- ANN HORNADAY,
The Washington Post
"It returns us to that time with immediacy, intelligence and
a full-bodied human impact. Instead of weepiness, it offers us insight
and revelation - and what James Joyce in The Dead called ‘generous
tears’...In our hype and glitz-ridden pop and political culture,
it may take a filmmaker like Greengrass to remind audiences that
the reality of humans wrestling with a complicated fate is the truest
source of shock and awe...There's no cheap uplift to their victory,
no pop catharsis. What's great about ‘United 93’ is
that you never feel it's just a movie--even though, as a movie,
it's terrific.” --MICHAEL SRAGOW, Baltimore
Sun
“If you see ‘United 93’ in a theater with a decent
sound system, you’ll notice in the control-center sequences
a continuous hubbub in the side speakers. On at least two occasions
I turned in annoyance, tempted to go out to the lobby and hush the
inconsiderate crowd. But the ubiquitous racket—the busyness,
the swerving camera—is part of Greengrass’s strategy.
Everything is moving very, very fast and at the same time, in the
slowest slow motion. It’s a frantic paralysis.” --DAVID
EDELSTEIN, New York Magazine
“An unflinching, powerfully visceral and haunting portrait
of the tragic events aboard one of the terrorist-commandeered flights
on the fateful morning of Sept. 11, 2001...it is undeniably the
most gut-wrenching and captivating film released this year...Filmed
in real time and shot with handheld cameras, it has the urgency
and grit of a documentary rather than a big-studio movie. We will
never know exactly what transpired aboard that flight, but ‘United
93’ gives us an educated guess.” --CLAUDIA
PUIG, USA Today
“There's not an ounce of Hollywood bull in this movie's 111
minutes...Beamer's famous ‘Let's roll’ comment is delivered
off-the-cuff, not like a battle cry in a bogus action flick. We
will never know whether the passengers actually breached the cockpit.
What matters to Greengrass is their collective intent. At the end,
he imagines a sea of arms reaching into that cockpit in a way that
redefines heroism. Far from being exploitive, the effect is inspiring:
This is the best of us.” --PETER TRAVERS,
Rolling Stone
If a movie had to be made about the Newark-to-San Francisco flight
that crashed in Pennsylvania when passengers tried to retake it
from 9/11 hijackers, British writer-director Paul Greengrass did
it as well as it could possibly be done...It is a docudrama done
with great sensitivity, and with unerring judgment in the writing
and in the depiction of the passengers and hijackers...No one can
accuse Greengrass of exploitation. But you can certainly question
the point of making a movie that--when it ends at the moment of
93's impact--leaves us with the same sickening mix of loss and anger
we felt at the time.” --JACK MATHEWS,
The New York Daily News
|