|
YOUNG ADAM
A Scottish drifter who wants to be a novelist
takes a job on a barge traveling between Glasgow and Edinburgh and
strikes erotic sparks with his bosss wife. One morning the
body of a nearly nude woman surfaces in the canal, and, as we soon
learn, this is not the first time the drifter has seen the woman.
CAST: Ewan McGregor, Tilda Swinton,
Peter Mullan, Emily Mortimer, Therese Bradley, Ewan Stewart, Stuart
McQuarrie, Pauline Turner, Alan Cooke, Rory McCann
DIRECTOR: David Mackenzie
"Ewan
McGregor has a jumpy ferocity that makes him perfect for the role.
Even sitting still, smoking a hand-rolled cigarette or reading a
tattered paperback, he radiates a feverish, slightly dangerous intensity,
a charisma disproportionate to Joe's modest, straitened surroundings
In
the end, Joe's sexuality, while exhibited with quite a bit more
explicitness than the old movies would permit, is also what makes
Young Adam feel most dated. Its view of male narcissism,
as expressed through erotic need, is not only uncritical but also
pretentious
Joe is an intellectual construct as much as a person,
and the people whose lives he wrecks are moral abstractions."
--A.O. Scott, The New York Times
"The movie is another showcase for the underappreciated McGregor,
who disappears into his character so discreetly that, even as his
face lets us track Joes every thought, you never feel youre
watching a Performance. Hes not a self-serious Method man
like Sean Penn, whose work seems designed to make us think, What
a powerful piece of acting!
a portrait of the artist
as a selfish young bastard, a man who thinks the world around him
is soiled, and finds it just terrible, but wants to believe that,
in the final analysis, it has nothing to do with him." --John
Powers, LA Weekly
"Something
lupine and predatory skulks at the edges of Ewan McGregor's screen
persona
McGregor's latent menace leaves a phantom watermark
on blank-page Joe, who uses and discards his lovers and employers
as affectlessly as he does his omnipresent cigarettes. (If Joe isn't
smoking, he must be fucking.)
the movie's fiercest assets lie
in its formidable cast: Emily Mortimer (as Joe's wheedling ex-flame,
Cathie), McGregor, and especially Swinton (above, with McGregor)
are as frank and fearless with their NC-17 naked bodies as Mackenzie
is uncompromised in conveying Trocchi's sulfurous purview on labor
and lust to the screen
Young Adam doesn't quite
know how to take its leave; it tapers off like a curling cigarette
trail, but it lingers like a ghost." --Jessica Winter, The
Village Voice
"With its arthouse cast, hipster credentials and ominous atmosphere,
Young Adam never bothers to reach for real significance
the
story begins with the discovery of one dead body and ends with the
specter of another. Things rarely pick up in between
sex scenes
so frank, they earned an NC-17 rating. And yet, shot in the same
grim, gritty style as the rest of the film, they're hardly more
exciting than anything else. While Mackenzie sees poetry in the
moody David Byrne score, the carefully shot wisps of smoke and the
sullen stares, others may find only pretension." --Elizabeth
Weitzman, The New York Daily News
"The fact that we see Cathie and Joe and Ella in full frontally-nude
detail may be one of the reasons the MPAA saddled Young Adam
with the infamous NC-17 rating, thereby putting the film in the
spotlight for the wrong reasons. What you should really know about
writer-director David Mackenzies unsparing adaptation of the
late Alexander Trocchis cult novel is that it is brilliantly
interpreted by its four leadsEwan McGregor as the drifter,
Tilda Swinton and Peter Mullan as the victims of his manipulation,
and Emily Mortimer as the lady of mystery
even at its most
unnerving, it is a richly atmospheric, perversely satisfying drama."
--Guy Flatley, Moviecrazed
"Everything about this adaptation shows it to be a labour of
love
It's a dreamy, disquieting study of sexual tension and
guilty secrets. The movie drifts downriver, like the tatty barge
on which it's set, towards its finale at a sensational murder trial
It
has its faults -- implausibility and absurdity in its sexual imbroglios
and a narrative structure that tends towards the elusive. But this
is really impressive, accomplished work from Mackenzie, who is showing
himself to be a natural film-maker
For my money, this is the
best performance of Ewan McGregor's career by a long way: subtle
and complex." --Peter Bradshaw, The Guardian
"This noirish character study starring Ewan McGregor doesn't
glamorize or idealize sex or set out to titillate
David Mackenzie's
assured film is less a thriller than an open-ended exploration of
Joe's amoral behavior
Besides terrific performances, it boasts
terrific cinematography by Giles Nuttgens that contrasts stunningly
beautiful and grimly ugly Scottish landscapes -- complementing the
hunky Joe's ugly soul, which manifests itself in a truly nasty sex
scene involving pudding, catsup and Cathie."--Lou Lumenick,
The New York Post
"Steamy sex and the sight of Ewan McGregor's dick -- he's having
it on with married Tilda Swinton -- got this otherwise tepid movie,
directed by David Mackenzie, slapped with an NC-17. The adultery
and murder that follow when McGregor signs on to work for Swinton
and her husband (Peter Mullan), on a barge navigating the waterways
of Glasgow, elicit only stifled yawns." --Peter Travers, Rolling
Stone
"Rich atmospherics and an all-star British cast make this a
superior melodrama if you can handle the heavy-breathing sex scenes."
--David Sterritt, The Christian Science Monitor
"Portraying an emotionally amputated protagonist without either
soliciting sympathy or alienating your audience is no mean trick
David Mackenzie, in his second feature as writer-director, takes
his own route but still hits the target
Mackenzie handles his
material with a light touch and intimate attention to physical detail:
the sense of grimy, sweaty flesh, especially in the sex scenes on
the barge, is startlingly vivid." --Philip Kemp, Sight and
Sound
"What David Mackenzie really wants to explore is the idea of
original sin, and even if his methods are suspect (I'm not sure
how a violent sex scene involving homemade custard and ketchup helps
us get back to the Garden) he has succeeded in creating an interesting
study of self-immolation
McGregor, delivering one of his strongest
acting performances, displays the raw sexuality and easy charm that
would attract seemingly every woman in Glasgow, while nailing the
self-loathing that fuels Joe's compulsions
Mackenzie's movie
may come up short allegorically, but it gets the torpid disaffection
just right." -- Glenn Whipp, The Los Angeles Times
"Despite the noirish love triangle, barge-bound claustrophobia,
and hints of murder-mystery, Young Adam isnt a
thriller. Instead Mackenzie and his solid cast craft a mood-piece
character study of the amoral, perpetually priapic Joe who
screws every adult female character with a speaking part
Unfortunately,
the wall-to-wall sex turns out to be the most distinctive feature
of Young Adam a slightly depressing retreat into professional
film-making after the ragged delights of Mackenzies The
Last Great Wilderness. This follow-up, while much more even,
sustained and stylish, could do with a little of that pictures
anything-goes energy." --Neil Young, Jigsaw Lounge
|