|
VERONICA GUERIN
The true story of a driven Dublin journalist
who was murdered by the drug dealers she had exposed.
CAST: Cate Blanchett, Gerard McSorley, Ciaran Hinds, Brenda Fricker,
Don Wycherley, Barry Barnes, Simon ODriscoll, Emmet Bergin
DIRECTOR: Joel Schumacher
"Veronica
Guerin, a fearless Dublin journalist murdered by powerful drug dealers,
was a real-life heroine who deserves better than Veronica
Guerin, an example of Hollywood schlock from the team of Joel
Schumacher (director) and Jerry Bruckheimer (producer) that lacks
the faintest trace of imagination or genuine feeling
It cannot
be overstated that there is nothing in Veronica Guerin
-- visually, verbally or even musically -- that is not a cliché
Though
the filmmakers are clearly anxious to portray Guerin as a martyred
saint, she comes across at first as irritatingly, inexplicably smug
and later, naive to the point of stupidity." --Jonathan Foreman,
The New York Post
"There's no airbrushing of character. She's played with intelligence
whipped clean of any airs and poses by the always cleanly intelligent
Cate Blanchett, who makes Guerin a 3-D woman, not a 2-D heroine
Her
death was shocking; this well-made telling of her life is inspiring."
--Lisa Schwarzbaum, Entertainment Weekly
"
a flat-footed, overwrought crusader-against-evil melodrama,
in which Ms. Blanchett's formidable gifts as an actress are reduced
to a haircut and an accent
the filmmakers have succeeded in
making Guerin's fascinating story tedious and formulaic, and in
making a real-life drama seem as phony as mediocre television
the
storytelling is so clumsy that very little intrigue develops. Nor
does much genuine emotion, a defect that Mr. Schumacher tries to
overcome with clever editing and loud, swelling music. Veronica
Guerin is disappointing in its lazy glibness; it wastes a
somber and heroic story that could have made a fine movie."
--A.O. Scott, The New York Times
"I kept imagining the movie it might have been before director
Joel Schumacher and producer Jerry Bruckheimer got their hands on
it. A great subject has been slicked up
As might be expected,
her story is heavily weighted toward blood and bullets; we never
feel that we know this woman as anything but a crusader
Blanchett
has the right white-hot intensity to play Guerin
But shes
never allowed to develop much subtlety or richness, because the
filmmakers keep upping the mayhem
A character as psychologically
complex as Guerinwhose drive may not have been fully comprehensible
even to herselfneeds a lot of room to expand on screen. Schumacher
and Bruckheimer box her in." --Peter Rainer, New York Magazine
"
a powerful, no-nonsense, well-made engrosser that offers
another strong star vehicle for the ever-rising Cate Blanchett
Blanchett
is, warts-and-all, letter perfect. Assuming an Irish brogue that
never gets theatrical and never lets down, she powers through this
movie with the riveting intensity and aching, poignant credibility
of Meryl Streep in her prime." --William Arnold, Seattle Post-Intelligencer
"Cate Blanchett plays Guerin in a way that fascinated me for
reasons the movie probably did not intend. I have a sneaky suspicion
that director Joel Schumacher and his writers (Carol Doyle and Mary
Agnes Donoghue) think of this as a story of courage and determination,
but what I came away with was a story of bone-headed egocentrism
We
cringe at the flamboyant risks she takes
Their Veronica Guerin
dies, essentially, because the excitement of a great story robs
her of all common sense." --Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times
"As played by Cate Blanchett, Guerin's motives cannot fully
be surmised, even by herself. She's an altruist, to be sure, but
also a careerist, a noodge and an extrovert with a relentless competitive
streak
Our sense that Veronica's pursuit is just a little bit
neurotic and even possibly not worth it makes it all the more interesting,
emphasizing the protagonist's unique nature while lending a note
of ambiguity
A fraction of the people who see Kill Bill
or Charlie's Angels will see Veronica Guerin,
but this is the real girl-power movie." --Mick LaSalle, San
Francisco Chronicle
"The film presents Guerin as so heedless and unreflective in
her crusade that it makes you believe she actively provoked her
murder
the character's confidence is so impregnable that she
must have the fear literally beaten into her
the film is missing
any sense of outrage or shock or politics
a self-congratulatory
exercise in poor taste
Seediness and violence are what really
turn the movie on. Schumacher and Bruckheimer can't seem to help
themselves. These are the same people who brought you such leering
and lurid entertainments as 8MM, Coyote Ugly,
and television's CSI. True to their natures, they've
come up with an action flick passing as a eulogy." --Wesley
Morris, The Boston Globe
"Vigorously directed by Joel Schumacher, the film is closer
to a suspense thriller than a journalistic report. But it gains
energy and credibility from skillful acting by a largely Irish cast,
including such standbys as Brenda Fricker and Gerard McSorley. Not
to mention Ms. Blanchett, even if she does hail from Australia rather
than Ireland itself. She's a charismatic star whose presence in
the Oscar race wouldn't surprise me in the least." --David
Sterritt, The Christian Science Monitor
"Blanchett carries this earnest bit of hagiography from director
Joel Schumacher. She brings class, dignity and charm to the standard
Erin Brockovich type, the sexy crusader pursuing The Good against
all odds. She is not a vamp. Nor is she a pit-bull journalist. She
is charisma incarnate
Blanchett makes a tragic figure come
to life with such richness that her death hits home." --Philip
Kennicott, The Washington Post
"There are some baffling inconsistencies
Could someone
as street-smart and savvy as Guerin really have been so oblivious
in the last minutes of her life as to fail to notice several murderers
lying in wait?
Wouldn't she keep an eye out, given her status
as a target of vicious criminals?
the film belongs to Blanchett,
whose star turn as the brazen, cocky and committed journalist lingers
well after the credits have rolled." --Claudia Puig, USA Today
|