|
TEARS OF THE SUN
A super-tough SEAL lieutenant
attempts to rescue a beautiful American doctor from a genocidal
bloodbath in Nigeria, but she refuses to go with him unless he agrees
to take along her patients.
CAST: Bruce Willis, Monica Bellucci, Cole Hauser,
Eamonn Walker, Nick Chinlund, Fionnula Flanagan, Malick Bowens,
Tom Skerritt
DIRECTOR: Antoine Fuqua
"The
film is a strictly no-bull proposition: Bruce Willis, who never
met a quip he didn't like, has been enjoined to keep his yap shut
and play his team leader's role with wary grace and almost pure
silence. I don't think he cracks wise even once. He just looks,
as soldiers do and are, really tired most of the time. He doesn't
even kiss the girl, and since the girl is Monica Bellucci, that
gives you some idea of his discipline!
There's no speechifying,
and when the guys go to the radio, the militarese they spout has
the terse poetics of the actual stuff
Fuqua also recognizes
the weird beauty of soldiers. Whether this is homoerotic or just
erotic, I am not sure
This film offers up a good portfolio
of what might be called commando calendar art: It's full of dirty,
haggard men in sweaty camouflage battle dress, festooned with ammo
belts and tattoos, laboring under a load of automatic weapons that
would break a donkey's back, who look simply gorgeous." --Stephen
Hunter, The Washington Post
"Theres a sequence about midway through the movie, as
the Americans come across a village where a few dozen rebel soldiers
are engaging in the sort of ethnic cleansing one would like to think
simply isn't possible in a civilized world, that's about as harrowing
as anything likely to show up on movie screens this year
It's
a shame the filmmakers weren't always able to resist their baser
instincts, throwing in cheap cinematic shots that only take away
from the film's nobler urges. Casting the classically beautiful
Bellucci as a jungle doctor didn't have to be as silly as it sounds;
in fact, she throws herself into the role with gusto, evincing mettle
that matches anything Willis can do. But dressing her in a button-down
shirt strategically open to the third or fourth button is cheap
and gratuitous, undermining both her performance and the movie itself."
--Chris Kaltenbach, The Baltimore Sun
"Antoine Fuqua, who directed the fine Training Day,
reportedly set out to make a serious movie about African genocide,
but was pressured by his hawkish star into turning out a schmaltzy
ode to U.S. military involvement that tacitly endorses the impending
Iraqi invasion
The result is a sluggish, confused flick with
a frighteningly taciturn Willis in Die Hard/John Wayne
mode--the Wayne of The Green Berets, not The Searchers
The
film leaves the inescapable impression that Walters is motivated
less by humanitarian reasons than Dr. Kendricks' habit of forgetting
to fully button her blouse." --Lou Lumenick, The New York Post
"The filmmakers chose to invent their own third-world conflict,
and rather than follow the time-honored Hollywood tradition of confecting
some wholly fictitious San Something-or-other or Whereverstan, they
decided to plunge the actual nation of Nigeria into bloody chaos
the
movie's real setting is a sentimental fantasy world, and its story
is a spectacularly incoherent exercise in geopolitical wish fulfillment
The
Americans come upon a village in the middle of a massacre and, with
furious professionalism, cleanse it of ethnic cleansers. Then they
reconnoiter and declare their willingness to sacrifice their lives
to bring their charges to safety, and their resolve is met with
tears of gratitude. The audience's tears are more likely to result
from boredom, irritation at Hans Zimmer's wretched fake-world-music
score and inadvertent amusement at the thunderously earnest dialogue
and Ms. Bellucci's awkward line readings. (She has now made movies
in three languages; whether she can act in any of them is an open
question.)" --A.O. Scott, The New York Times
"The movies noble aspirations
are clearBosnia and Rwanda were obviously on the filmmakers
mindsyet its hopelessly steeped in stale Hollywood action
conventions
Director Antoine Fuqua, who did well with Training
Day, flip-flops here between slaughter and solemnity, and
his unvarying adagio pace only gives the cliches more time to expose
themselves. And just now Tears of the Sun plays shamelessly
into the hands of the Iraq war hawks, down to the on-screen Edmund
Burke quote that ends the film: The only thing necessary for
the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing. Was this
what the filmmakers had in mind when they started?" --David
Ansen, Newsweek
"
a surprisingly anti-authoritarian version of a hero's
story, casting Willis as the ultimate military pragmatist, who prizes
expediency and completion of mission above all else. But after exposure
to this particular strain of man's inhumanity to man, he suddenly
realizes that his orders and his duty are two different things.
It's a bold notion to be offering in these times
It's the kind
of movie where five guys with handguns and grenades, with only tall
grass as their cover, can hold off an entire army equipped with
machine guns
Willis is in tough, terse mode, a stoic struggling
to suppress his own humanity. Bellucci is mostly pouty; as a doctor
meant to appear stubbornly sacrificing, she seems mostly like a
participant in the Barbies Without Borders program." --Marshall
Fine, The Journal News
"Whatever else this movie is about -- and it most obviously
is about shooting, killing and blowing things up Tears
is most concerned with humanization
The film is set up so we're
happy when the S.E.A.L. unit violates its orders
Rwanda is
never mentioned, but its horrors -- and the world's shame for looking
the other way -- is never far from mind
What's noteworthy is that Tears is simultaneously a
gripping action tale and a plea for a policy of engagement, of humanitarian
intervention, in parts of the world where oil is not at stake. It
isn't the type of war movie we expect, and we certainly don't expect
Willis, a George W. Bush supporter, to star in it." --Eric
Harrison, Houston Chronicle
"It has a stronger sense of
combat's real costs and consequences than more sensationalistic
pictures like Black Hawk Down and We Were Soldiers
provide. Too bad it doesn't take as much care to detail the humanity
of its characters--or reasons for its politics--as it does to build
ominous battlefield moods." --David Sterritt, The Christian
Science Monitor
|