|
SOMETHINGS GOTTA
GIVE
An aging womanizer who never dates women
over 30 is astonished to find himself drawn to the mother of his
latest nubile tootsie.
CAST: Jack Nicholson, Diane Keaton, Keanu Reeves, Amanda Peet,
Frances McDormand, Jon Favreau, Nichole Hiltz
DIRECTOR: Nancy Meyers
"In
the gift-wrapped role of divorced, middle-aged famous playwright
Erica Barry, Keaton glows with the beauty of a mature, self-aware
woman
what woman wouldn't want to be Keaton, all sexy, funny,
tender, quick, and never more charismatic in her animated access
to her own feelings? And what man, of any age, wouldn't want to
be with her?
Something says nothing particularly
pithy about the vulnerability of aging eyes dependent on reading
glasses or about aging libidos grateful for Viagra. But every moment
spent in the company of Keaton is such a joy that the whole is more
delightful than the sum of the formulaic ingredients." --Lisa
Schwarzbaum, Entertainment Weekly
"Diane Keaton is so rarely in movies anymore that seeing her
in even the half-baked Somethings Gotta Give is
a blessing
Except for briefly in Reds, Keaton and
Nicholson have never worked together, and, in a sense, they still
havent. They look great side by side, but Meyers puts them
through so much middling slapstick its like theyre auditioning
for a Fox sitcom
yet, Keaton at times manages to convert Meyerss
penchant for the obvious into something truly funny
Even in
a piffle like Somethings Gotta Give, Keaton reminds
us of her uncanny ability to inhabit her characters knockabout
emotions
Nobody can be grave and goofy all at once like Diane
Keaton. In these fractious times, its the perfect combo for
a modern heroine." --Peter Rainer, New York Magazine
"Diane Keaton, looking smashing at fifty-seven, lands her sexiest,
wittiest role in years as Erica Barry, a divorced playwright who
has learned to do without men. Keaton nails every laugh and nuance
in this tart, terrific romantic comedy from writer-director Nancy
Meyers. She steals your heart and the movie. It's a pleasure to
watch her co-star and pal Jack Nicholson hand her the show
in
an era of dumb farce, Something's Gotta Give is something
special." --Peter Travers, Rolling Stone
"The harder Erica cried, the harder the audience laughed,
which I might have found disturbing if I had not been laughing so
helplessly myself. This mirth was not cruel or derisive; it was
instead an odd but nonetheless apt measure of the audience's sympathy
and affection for Erica and a tribute to Ms. Keaton's unparalleled
comic skill. Nobody else working in movies today can make her own
misery such a source of delight or make the spectacle of utter embarrassment
look like a higher form of dignity
Mr. Nicholson has the gentlemanly
grace to step aside and let Ms. Keaton claim the movie. She in turn
brings out the best in everyone around her." --A.O. Scott,
The New York Times
"To complain that Nicholson is playing himself
-- or that Keaton is also playing a character very much like her
public persona -- is missing the point. Part of the appeal depends
on the movie's teasing confusion of reality and fiction
They
bring so much experience, knowledge and humor to their characters
that the film works in ways the screenplay might not have even hoped
for." --Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times
"Though the part was written for Keaton, it seems to call for
a Jane Fonda or Sigourney Weaver or Meryl Streep. But if Keaton
is miscastor misdirectedshe has wonderful moments once
Ericas defenses come tumbling down. Bursting into tears of
joy, relief and gratitude after so many years without sex, shes
heartbreakingly vulnerable
Meyers drags the movie out too long
(two hours plus)
Yet the movie, which ricochets between farce
and poignancy, casts just enough romantic pixie dust to leave you
smiling." --David Ansen, Newsweek
"Its lack of cosmic weight aside, the film Meyers has fashioned
is generally quite amusing, with a brilliant cast
still, as
much fun as it occasionally is, there's a thin movie desperate to
get out of this very fat movie. Why does Nancy Meyers make such
long movies?
the denouement, in Paris, could have been wrapped
up in four minutes instead of 10. Billy Wilder would have done it
in two, the great Lubitsch in 30 seconds." --Stephen Hunter,
The Washington Post
"Nobody does lovable flibbertigibbet better than Diane Keaton
But
Keaton's overamped girlishness, and the adolescent shenanigans she
engages in, make a mockery of this overlong romantic comedy's stance
as a celebration of mature love. No matter how many times her successful,
middle-aged playwright, Erica Barry, is described by others as flinty,
formidable macho, even -- her giggles
and blushes and operatic wails demonstrate otherwise
The first
half of this frothy movie is a lark
But it's all downhill from
there." --Megan Lehmann, The New York Post
"Diane Keaton partially revisits her Oscar-winning neurotic
Annie Hall performance, albeit this time better dressed
and less likely to say things like la-de-da
It's
a lovely portrait of an older woman reawakened
For the film's
first hour, Meyers' dialogue sparkles; it's sheer bliss to watch
these two seasoned performers wrap their lips around those sweet
nuggets filled with laughter
Unfortunately, the plot soon runs
out of steam. Not only does Meyers add on increasingly ridiculous
plot twists and epilogues, but she also clocks the whole thing in
at just over two hours." --Jeffrey M. Anderson, The San Francisco
Examiner
"It's so delightful to see Diane Keaton back on top that it's
easy to brush aside the limitations of the midlife romantic comedy
Something's Gotta Give
Keaton gets star treatment
she hasn't enjoyed since her collaborations with Woody Allen
and she looks better in her nude scene here than in her last one,
26 years ago, in Looking for Mr. Goodbar
the movie
is sitcom material more than it is the screwball comedy it wants
to be. It is far too long and unevenly paced, despite its many tart
one-liners. And the ending is a cop-out." --Jami Bernard, The
New York Daily News
"As
Erica Barry, a successful divorced playwright in her late 50s, Keaton
is not only funny, she's grounded, without a hint of the old Annie
Hall neurasthenic dither
for most of the film, she's dry, warily
defended, and fantastically articulate. A revelation. The movie
itself reveals nothing, but it's entertaining
I love Nicholson
here because he lets Keaton take the movieand his relative
reticence is very attractive." --David Edelstein, Slate
"
as removed from everyday reality as most Hollywood fantasies
Meyers's
latest is worth seeing for its offbeat story, its tantalizing settings,
and most of all, its spot-on acting, especially by Keaton and Nicholson,
whose amazing chemistry doesn't quit for a second." --David
Sterritt, The Christian Science Monitor
|