|
ROAD TO PERDITION
Gangsters of The Great Depression betray and
murder one another, Chicago-style.
CAST: Tom Hanks, Paul Newman, Tyler Hoechlin,
Jude Law, Daniel Craig, Stanley Tucci, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Dylan
Baker, Ciarn Hinds, Liam Aiken, Doug Spinuzza, Diane Dorsey, Peggy
Roeder, James Greene
DIRECTOR: Sam Mendes
"...
a period gangster film that achieves the grandeur of a classic Hollywood
western...a truly majestic visual tone poem...'Road to Perdition'
ponders some of the same questions as 'The Sopranos,' a comparably
great work of popular art, whose protagonist is also a gangster
and a devoted family man. But far from a self-pitying boor lumbering
around a suburban basement in his undershirt, Mr. Hanks's antihero
is a stern, taciturn killer who projects a tortured nobility...Mr.
Newman's Rooney, with his ferocious hawklike glare, sepulchral rasp
and thunderous temper, has the ultimate power to bestow praise and
shame, to bless and to curse. The role, for which the 77-year-old
actor adopts a softened Irish brogue, is one of Mr. Newman's most
farsighted, anguished performances." --Stephen
Holden, The New York Times
"...self-conscious to the point of suffocation...much of the time
the technique is so studied it keeps you outside the story, like
a frame that overpowers the painting it's supposed to display...Hanks
delivers a subtle, brooding performance, but one that could have
used a touch more of the ferocity and anger he showed in 'Punchline'...
Newman makes an elegant elderly crime lord, utterly steely under
his paternal Irish bluster. Law's almost Kabuki-like performance
is striking in its quirky theatricality...Craig, the least familiar
face, makes a strong, scary impression as the detestable Connor.
But the movie's airless, overdetermined style doesn't allow them
the spark of spontaneity...The harder 'Road to Perdition' strives
to be Important, the less it has anything interesting to say." --David
Ansen, Newsweek
"... a solemnly beautiful art concept--perhaps the most thoroughly
stylized gangster picture since the Coen brothers' 'Miller's Crossing'...Hall's
palette is muted and precise, the action sudden, swift, and bloody.
Visually, the movie is all of a piece, and consistently impressive,
and I enjoyed some of it very much. But...this is a stilted, self-conscious
piece of work--a case of dark-toned academic classicism. There isn't
a joke or a touch of wit anywhere in the movie...For all the beauty
and power of 'Road to Perdition,' there's not much spontaneity in
it, and the movie's flawless surface puts a stranglehold on meaning."
--David Denby, The New Yorker
"With 'Road to Perdition,' Mendes gives the gangster genre an overweening
significance that, for the most part, it can't support. The pulp
shows clearly through the high-art preening: It isn't prominent
enough to be fun, and the art, with few exceptions, isn't high enough
to justify all the moody-blues meaningfulness...In the scenes between
Hanks and Newman, we get glimpses of greatness... When their mutual
fate is clear, there's an almost sensual abandon in the way they
give themselves up to it. Hanks and Newman are so finely attuned
to each other's mood that their dialogue seems like an encumbrance.
We don't need words--we have their eyes...Powerful as Hanks is in
the part, he is still required to play a man who, though a killer,
is a rather nice one...The reason 'Road to Perdition' unrolls so
smoothly and finishes so neatly is because Mendes doesn't give darkness
its due...Perdition has rarely looked so rosy." --Peter
Rainer, New York
"A flawed exploration of America's flirtation
with lawlessness and its love of guns, 'Road to Perdition' falls
short of such classics as 'The Godfather,' 'Miller's Crossing' and
'Prizzi's Honor.' Still, it packs a visceral and intellectual punch,
offers an awesome display of cinematic technique, and provides us
with the opportunity to see superstars Newman and Hanks at the top
of their serious-acting form. They're terrific together, even when
they're killing each other." --Guy
Flatley, Moviecrazed
"...a rare and exemplary work of artistry and humanity that makes
you think while it unfolds like the haunting pages of a novel you
never want to end. Hands down, it's the best film of the summer,
and already a contender for both the Oscars and my year-end 10 Best
List...Let's face it: Nothing on the screen can take the place of
great story-telling. The ability to tell a fascinating story coherently,
truthfully and entertainingly while engaging the emotions and stimulating
the mind is the essential element that separates the big films of
history from the majority of the wormy, pointless, creatively bankrupt
junk we've been getting lately. 'Road to Perdition' honors the tradition
wisely. It's a thoughtful and responsible film, at a time when we
need one badly." --
Rex Reed, The New York Observer
"Weep for the Sullivans in this sumptuous and predigested, top-quality
and overdetermined, serious and easy-reader movie, Mendes encourages,
but do not despair for them because--as in Mendes' manufactured
crowd-pleaser, 'American Beauty'--it's always darkest just before
the catharsis...there's much that's simplistically grand, worthy,
and fine in 'Perdition.' If I yearn for less measured filmmaking
that cries out with more reckless despair, it's because I think
hell on earth is a meaner, much more interesting, and far less tidy
cinematic place than Mendes trusts his audience to handle." --
Lisa Schwarzbaum, Entertainment Weekly
|