|
THE PASSION OF THE
CHRIST
The last 12 hours leading to the horrific
crucifixion of Jesus Christ are depicted in microscopic detail.
CAST: Jim Caviezel, Monica Bellucci, Hristo Naumov Shopov, Maia
Morgenstern, Francesco De Vito, Luca Lionello, Mattia Sbragia, Rosalinda
Celentano, Claudia Gerini
DIRECTOR: Mel Gibson
"The
Passion of the Christ is so relentlessly focused on the savagery
of Jesus' final hours that this film seems to arise less from love
than from wrath, and to succeed more in assaulting the spirit than
in uplifting it. Mr. Gibson has constructed an unnerving and painful
spectacle that is also, in the end, a depressing one. It is disheartening
to see a film made with evident and abundant religious conviction
that is at the same time so utterly lacking in grace
The
Passion of the Christ never provides a clear sense of what
all of this bloodshed was for, an inconclusiveness that is Mr. Gibson's
most serious artistic failure. The Gospels, at least in some interpretations,
suggest that the story ends in forgiveness. But such an ending seems
beyond Mr. Gibson's imaginative capacities. Perhaps he suspects
that his public prefers terror, fury and gore." --A.O. Scott,
The New York Times
"The movie Gibson has made from his personal obsessions is
a sickening death trip, a grimly unilluminating procession of treachery,
beatings, blood, and agony
Gibson is so thoroughly fixated
on the scourging and crushing of Christ, and so meagrely involved
in the spiritual meanings of the final hours, that he falls in danger
of altering Jesus message of love into one of hate
The
Passion, in its confused way, confirms the old justifications
for persecuting the Jews, and one somehow doubts that Gibson will
make a sequel in which he reminds the audience that in later centuries
the Church itself used torture and execution to punish not only
Jews but heretics, non-believers, and dissidents
one of the
cruellest movies in the history of the cinema." --David Denby,
The New Yorker
"This is the most violent film I have ever seen
This is
not a sermon or a homily, but a visualization of the central event
in the Christian religion
You must be prepared for whippings,
flayings, beatings, the crunch of bones, the agony of screams, the
cruelty of the sadistic centurions, the rivulets of blood that crisscross
every inch of Jesus' body
It is a personal message movie of
the most radical kind, attempting to re-create events of personal
urgency to Gibson. The filmmaker has put his artistry and fortune
at the service of his conviction and belief, and that doesn't happen
often
I myself am no longer religious in the sense that a long-ago
altar boy thought he should be, but I can respond to the power of
belief whether I agree or not, and when I find it in a film, I must
respect it." --Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times
"Mel Gibson's The Passion of the Christ is the
most virulently anti-Semitic movie made since the German propaganda
films of World War II
Jews are vilified, in ways both little
and big, pretty much nonstop for two hours, seven minutes
The
movie is a compendium of tortures that would horrify the regulars
at an S&M club
The Passion of the Christ is
a brutal, nasty film that demonizes Jews at an unfortunate time
in history." --Jami Bernard, The New York Daily News
"The Passion of the Christ is powerfully moving
and fanatically obtuse in equal doses
scenes range from classic
to poor and all stops in between
Jim Caviezel, who plays Jesus,
doesn't so much give a performance as offer himself up as raw meat.
So graphic are the torture scenes -- flayings, a crown of thorns,
whips with barbed metal tips, nails driven into hands and feet --
that the film seems like the greatest story ever told by the Marquis
de Sade
But Gibson's immersion in the blood of Christ is an
act of faith filmed with a zealot's rapture. It's a shame he has
no faith in audiences to feel Jesus' pain without rubbing their
noses in it." --Peter Travers, Rolling Stone
"To say that its the bloodiest story ever told is an
understatement; rarely has so much red stuff flowed in any movie
before
the Crucifixion, we are treated, in fetishistic detail, to nearly
two hours of scourging and flaying. By the time Jesus is nailed
to the Cross, you may be too numb to care
Gibsons fervor,
it seems to me, belongs as much to the realm of sadomasochism as
to Christian piety
The damage will be to those who come to
believe that Gibsons crimson tide, with its jacked-up excruciations,
is synonymous with true religious feeling." --Peter Rainer,
New York
"In dramatizing the torment of Jesus' last 12 hours, he has
made a serious, handsome, excruciating film that radiates total
commitment. Few mainstream directors have poured so much of themselves
into so uncompromising a production. Whatever the ultimate verdict
on Gibson's Passion, it's hard not to admire Gibson's passion. Or
his artistry
to charge the film with being anti-Semitic is
like saying those who oppose the Bush Administration's Iraq policy
are anti-American." --Richard Corliss, Time
"I have no doubt that Mel Gibson loves Jesus. From the evidence
of The Passion of the Christ, however, what he seems
to love as much is the cinematic depiction of flayed, severed, swollen,
scarred flesh and rivulets of spilled blood, the crack of bashed
bones and the groans of someone enduring the ultimate physical agony
It's
the sadism, not the alleged anti-Semitism, that is most striking
From
a purely dramatic point of view, the relentless gore is self-defeating.
I found myself recoiling from the movie, wanting to keep it at arm's
length
Instead of being moved by Christ's suffering, or awed
by his sacrifice, I felt abused by a filmmaker intent on punishing
an audience, for who knows what sins." --David Ansen, Newsweek
"This is a two-hour-and-six-minute snuff movieThe Jesus
Chainsaw Massacrethat thinks it's an act of faith. For Gibson,
Jesus is defined not by his teachings in lifeby his message
of mercy, social justice, and self-abnegation, some of it rooted
in the Jewish Torah, much of it defiantly personalbut by the
manner of his execution
Gibson uses every weapon in his cinematic
arsenal to drive home the agony of those last dozen hours
It
is almost a relief when the spikes are driven into his hands and
feetat least it means that his pain is almost over. What does
this protracted exercise in sadomasochism have to do with Christian
faith? I'm asking; I don't know." --David Edelstein, Slate
"I was held by the hushed, voyeuristic brutality of The
Passion of the Christ. Tempting as it may be to dismiss Mel
Gibson as a glorified pain freak, dressing up a martyrdom fantasy
in Aramaic and Latin, it would be more accurate, I think, to say
that the filmmaker, a Catholic fundamentalist, presents his torture-racked
vision of Jesus' last 12 hours on earth as a sacred form of shock
therapy
Then again, isn't there more, so much more, to Jesus'
spirit than the bloody endurance of his wounds?
The Passion
of the Christ' comes close to being a splatter film in which
the victim embraces his own dismemberment
The movie is blood-soaked
pop theology for a doom-laden time, its effect that of a gripping
yet reductive paradox: It lifts us downward." --Owen Gleiberman,
Entertainment Weekly
"Mel Gibson's serious, often brutally powerful film on the
last 12 hours of the life of Jesus is a passionate but gruesomely
physical picture
Gibson tries to do several things at once:
create a compelling drama of the familiar tale, make an exciting
movie, follow the Gospels and, through it all, pay witness to his
faith. Inevitably, he fails at some of his goals, especially that
of proselytizing his audience or building bridges
this Passion
has more power and gore than power and glory, more blood and guts
than blood and redemption. Focusing on the excruciating agony of
the flagellation and crucifixion, Gibson and Caviezel never really
take us deeply into Jesus' heart or soul." --Michael Wilmington,
Chicago Tribune
"In Gibson's crudely effective, blood-soaked epic Braveheart,
there was little compassion or feeling -- but a great deal of savage
brutality culminating in one of the torture scenes that Gibson has
relished as an actor. In Passion, the relish for pain
and bloody cruelty that has marked his career as both a director
and an actor -- a relish that would almost be sensual in the hands
of a less vulgar artist -- boils over into a full-blown fetish
Eventually,
Passion becomes a kind of pornographic catalog of Christ's
suffering. And like pornography, it's initially powerful but eventually
becomes numbing
The message of Jesus' death is all but drowned
in Gibson's morbid enthusiasm for shots of metal tearing flesh,
as if Christ was crucified so that Gibson -- along with his hard-working
make-up and sound people -- could indulge his obsession with torture."
--Jonathan Foreman, The New York Post
|