|
THE MAGDALENE SISTERS
Based on fact, this
is an account of the ungodly physical abuse and mental torture that
took place behind the walls of the prison-like Sisters of Mercy
convent in Dublin
CAST: Anne-Marie Duff, Dorothy Duffy, Geraldine
McEwan, Nora-Jane Noone, Eileen Walsh, Peter Mullan
DIRECTOR: Peter Mullan
"The
Magdalene Sisters is a fist of fury, a savage, sledgehammer
attack on questionable practices by Ireland's Catholic Church that
is so fierce and furious, such a rip-roaring exposé, that
the Vatican itself howled in outrage
Once inside, these women
were forbidden contact with the outside world, which returned the
favor by ignoring what went on behind the walls. The inmates were
forced to work without pay in the Magdalene's institutional laundries
and were in general treated like prisoners
Unabashedly outraged
by the injustices of the system, Mullan and his cast have created
a fierce piece of agitprop cinema that is as merciless as the system
it is driven to expose
while Sisters is a machine
constructed to devastate audiences, its pared-down, neorealistic
style keeps the story from feeling excessive. Graced with performers
who bring a purity of emotion to their work, the film is always
dramatically convincing." --Kenneth Turan, The Los Angeles
Times
"This is a vital, responsible and powerful film to which attention
must be paid. I have seen it twice, and remain devastated
Despite
the elements of Grand Guignol that lurk from every shadow in this
film, the shocking conditions and events depicted in The Magdalene
Sisters are completely true
Mullan has distilled the
gruesome details of so much human suffering into an effectively
paced narrative that tells a grim story coherently, with cinematic
passion that never flinches from raw details
The Catholic church
has a lot to answer for, but if the bedlam over pedophile priests
still carries salty wounds, wait till they get a look at The Magdalene
Sisters. For me, its a great film that deserves genuflection."
--Rex Reed, The New York Observer
"Mullans rage at religious hypocrisy sometimes gets the
better of himhe admits almost no furtive flashes of cheer
into his chamber of horrorsbut his righteousness has a factual
base: Many of the incidents depicted were derived from an extensively
researched British TV documentary, Sex in a Cold Climate.
When it comes time for some of the girls to flee, the result is
one of the most emotionally satisfying of all prison breaks."
--Peter Rainer, New York Magazine
"Played by Geraldine McEwan with a steely collectedness that
makes the blood run cold, Sister Bridget lords over a Magdalene
asylum, one of the several laundry- cum-work camps in Ireland where
bad Catholic girls were sequestered for years -- lifetimes, in some
cases -- in order to have their sins washed away
Director-writer
Mullan masterfully infuses dramatic conventions more commonly found
in a concentration camp saga or a women-behind-bars picture with
the primal appeal of a tale by the Brothers Grimm
An accomplished
actor himself, Mullan elicits top-flight performances across the
board, led by the magnificent McEwan." --Jan Stuart, Newsday
"In a brilliant performance, Ms. McEwan makes this character
horribly believable by portraying her cruelty not as raw sadism
but as righteous punishment dispensed by a religious fanatic with
a warped sense of values
The Magdalene Sisters
more than fulfills the promise of Mr. Mullan's audacious feature
film debut, Orphans
The Magdalene Sisters
would be too painful to watch if it didn't have a silver lining.
Suffice it say that it is possible to fly over this religious cuckoo's
nest and remain free." --Stephen Holden, The New York Times
"Geraldine McEwan is fiercely magnificent as Sister Bridget,
letting flickers of humanity shine through the cruelty. Mullan errs
by making all the sisters dragon ladies. Still, the film gets to
you; it's a powerhouse." --Peter Travers, Rolling Stone
"Sister Bridget and her ilk are mere cartoons and the violence
they wield is so numbing that the film borders on the preposterous.
There's no discernable structure to this facile, episodic torture
mechanism yet Mullan hopes that you'll approach this film as a work
of activism. That Magdalene Sisters arrives stateside
with the full censure of the Vatican more or less confirms Mullan's
job-well-done." --Ed Gonzalez, Slant Magazine
"Though the Catholic Church hasnt been all that keen
on admitting it, the Magdalene Laundries, as they were also called,
really existed and were, by many accounts, even worse than the dungeonlike
sweatshop depicted in Mullans film
rather than simply
wagging his finger at the Church, Mullan (who is, like both the
heroines and the villainesses of his film, Catholic) canvasses a
broader terrain, faulting not any one particular system of organized
belief, but the blind submission by any group of people to any such
system. He is as ashamed as he is outraged, not at Catholicism itself,
but at its exploitation by those entrusted to uphold its principles
and by those who would knowingly lock up their daughters to wash
away the sins of an entire nation." --Scott Foundas, LA Weekly
"This is hard, often harrowing story-telling, about women who
lose all faith in life while forced into servitude for cruel jailers
who themselves supposedly are guided by faith
It's tough material,
presented honestly without sensationalism by a cast of young actors
who give searing performances." --Marshall Fine, The Journal
News
"The Magdalene Sisters is basically a women-in-prison
moviein which the innocent prisoners (generally referred to
as hoors) are isolated from the world and subjected
to a hideous, spirit-crushing regime of constant work, continual
browbeating, and total degradation
The unrelenting situation
is rendered all the more claustrophobic by the many close-ups
This
shocker is often shameless, not least in the climactic confrontation
with Sister Bridget, but it's impossible not to be moved by the
endingif only because the torture is finally over." --J.
Hoberman, The Village Voice
"Instantly condemned by the Catholic Church and protested by
nuns at its award-winning Venice Film Festival premiere, The
Magdalene Sisters offers a kind of worst-case glimpse into
the draconian Magdalene Asylums that were begun in the late 19th
century and lasted well into the 1990s
Mullan has been criticized
for condensing the extreme abuses of asylums into an overloaded
melodrama, and he does, but I don't fault him for it. That women
of legal age were held against their will by the church is a ghastly
violation of human rights in any civilized culture
The whole
system was sadistic and indefensible, and the church, looking the
other way as long as profits rolled in from the laundries, deserves
the scorn that Mullan and his fine cast heap on it." --Jack
Mathews, The New York Daily News
"The Magdalene Sisters is a pungent, powerful film
that points an accusing finger not at religious beliefs but at flawed
human institutions. It also targets social and cultural mores that
are almost medieval in their patriarchal bias against girls and
women
Peter Mullans fictionalized screenplay brings awful
realities to vivid life, reminding us that piety without compassion
is meaningless." --David Sterritt, The Chistian Science Monitor
"Mullan triggers all your emotions anger,
sorrow, pity, disgust, shame. And once he gets hold of you, he won't
let go. The story may get a tad sappy and contrived one girl
is freed by her brother on Christmas Day but you're hooked.
You'll walk away amazed at the heartlessness of the people running
the asylums and wondering how such a gruesome practice could have
existed into the late 20th century." --V.A. Musetto, The New
York Post
|