|
THE LAST SAMURAI
A heavy-drinking, guilt-consumed
Civil War veteran is persuaded by a budding Japanese industrialist
to sober up and come help rid his country of roving bands of samurai
warriors.
CAST: Tom Cruise, Ken Watanabe, Billy Connolly,
Masao Harada, Timothy Spall, Tony Goldwyn, William Atherton, Scott
Wilson, Togo Igawa
DIRECTOR: Edward Zwick
"The
Last Samurai is an example of the bizarre logic of Old Hollywood,
in which tens of millions of dollars are spent on authentic rice
paper and functioning waterwheels in order to prop up an entertaining
but entirely inauthentic fantasyan American showing up to
revive the samurai tradition...Most of the movie is pitched at the
level of high-flown cliché and achieves commercial eloquence
but nothing more...Cruises sensitive exchanges in beginners
Japanese with a beautiful widow seem to have been conceived for
a late-period Richard Chamberlain TV movie
The movie comes
close to dying between battle scenes."
--David Denby, The New Yorker
"The movie is an unabashed Cruise star
vehicle and a sometime mangling of Japanese history. But it also
has feeling, grace and spirit
it's done with such visual beauty
and thrilling action that, by the time of the film's climactic battle
-- the samurais' last stand against the imperial army -- we're swept
into its grand myth-making
What The Last Samurai
lacks, ultimately, is the sense of comic fire and danger, the roaring
gusto, that were the specialties of Kurosawa and his great samurai
star, tigerish Toshiro Mifune
but it's miles ahead of most
of the gadget-ridden adventure epics around now." --Michael
Wilmington, Chicago Tribune
"Under its beauty, its lush production values and its superficial
spell of enchantment, the basic product feels lame and thin, wan
and stale
battles are reasonably well staged, and lots of
people die. There's some cool sword-fighting. But still, it's junk
you
can feel the handsome little guy acting with every fiber
of his being. It's kind of unsettling. He resembles Sean Penn in
I Am Sam, except he seems to be shouting I Am
Samurai
He's a poster boy for the concept of trying
too hard. He's not a hero, he's the guy at the party who's
so intense you want him to stay away
This movie yearns for
a medieval country to remain medieval. What sane person could buy
into such absurdity?" --Stephen Hunter, The Washington Post
"Its like we're in a pre-9/11 time warp. It's weird
to watch, nowadays, a film in which the American hero is seduced
by the other side's warlord to fight against his own barbarian
capitalist countryto see the multiplex audience cheer a man
who it could well, in a slightly different context, want to see
tried and executed... Cruise gives a confident superstar performance
and one with no off-putting 19th-century period airs
The finale
of The Last Samurai is a blood-engorged orgy that ends
with a quasi-erotic embrace between two bullet-ridden warriors.
You can't really hate a war that ends with the senseless death of
thousands when it gives rise to the year's most romantic clinch."
--David Edelstein, Slate
"Ed Zwick and producer-star Tom Cruise have made a 19th century
epic that gains its power by tapping into a host of contemporary
terrors: the fear of modern weaponry, of cold commerce destroying
nature and ancient culture, and of a vanishing American integrity.
Cruise's undeniable star voltage makes it all palatable, and the
film is gorgeous to behold
Just don't pinch yourself when Cruise
comes riding up dressed as a samurai. There are moments in the film
where, if the audience were to step back, even for a second, the
whole edifice might collapse under a cascade of derisive laughter.
For a man best known for his smile, Cruise takes himself very seriously."
--Mick LaSalle, San Francisco Chronicle
"Tom Cruise has never demonstrated remarkable emotional depthhes
so ferociously present as a performer that even his reflective moments
can seem showy. It is to his credit here that he often succeeds
in giving Algren an inner life that is not simply a scaled-down
version of his outer one. We dont register Algrens need
for redemption as simply a plot device. He looks genuinely stricken
by his past
The Last Samurai is an idyll in which
the savageries of existence are transcended by spiritual devotion.
Thats a beautiful dream, and it gives the film a deep pleasingness,
but the fullness of life and its blackest ambiguities are sacrificed."
--Peter Rainer, New York Magazine
"The Last Samurai is both insane and not insane
enough
Zwick, a sensible-souled filmmaker with gaudy romantic
aspirations, never grounds Cruise's self-hate in anything more than
a hazy flashback. Wouldn't the slaughter at Gettysburg have traumatized
him as much as the Indian Wars? Zwick doesn't touch on that irony,
because he knows he can get away with pandering to contemporary
notions of white Western guilt for destroying other races and subcultures
The
nutty, masochistic high-mindedness might be funny if it weren't
so square, and so woefully inappropriate to the carnage. In The
Last Samurai, the body count is almost as high as the dead-brain-cell
count." --Michael Sragow, The Baltimore Sun
"Tom Cruise, the can-do idol of millions, uses his polished-chrome
smile mirthlessly. At least for the first hour, his grin looks like
a faded tattoo
Mr. Cruise comes off as too contemporary for
the 19th century at one point, he seems to be waiting for
a cellphone call to confirm his terms for a cover of Details magazine."
--Elvis Mitchell, The New York Times
"The Last Samurai," in which Tom Cruise teaches
the 19th-century Japanese to respect their own warrior traditions,
is a crock -- a pandering epic that's as phony as it is condescending
Beyond
a rampaging vanity that makes it almost impossible for him show
vulnerability, Cruise is a drastically limited actor whose serious
repertoire consists almost entirely of narrowing his eyes while
flashing his famous teeth. And boy, do we see a lot of those eyes
and teeth in a movie that often slows to a crawl to accommodate
endless closeups of the star, surely the most influential of the
10 credited producers." --Lou Lumenick, The New York Post
"Perhaps no other country treats its popular heroes as lavishly
as America, and no other country disowns them as bluntly. This can
happen when too much success is further burdened by profligacy (Mike
Tyson), eccentricity (Michael Jackson), misogyny (Martha Stewart)
or, in the case of Tom Cruise, Scientology. It's hard to find anyone
eager to sing praises for Cruise these days
the film's romanticized
idealization of old-world samurai values, at the expense of Westernized
progress, manages to come off as reactionary and liberal pleading
at the same time. Through it all, Tom Cruise stares soulfully past
the camera, on toward a catering truck where sushi rolls and ham
sandwiches dwell side by side in harmony." --Jan Stuart, Newsday
"Nothing about The Last Samurai rings as false
as Tom Cruise
when he was younger, he sparked with promise,
giving strong character performances in both Rain Man
and Born on the Fourth of July
Then the actor
hit it even bigger, developed a degree of creative control over
his movies and began doing cautious, overly calculated turns where
he seemed terminally outside the character, never letting us too
close, always keeping one eye cast on maintaining his hard-earned
celebrity. In effect, Cruise stopped being an actor and took up
the full-time job of being Tom Cruise
there are stretches in
which its possible to sit back and let The Last Samurai
wash over us, in the way that we might take pleasure in a prefab
Oriental antique that we know is phony. But then we snap out of
the trance and find ourselves craving something more." --Scott
Foundas, LA Weekly
"The Last Samurai claims to commemorate aspects
of ancient Japanese culture. Yet it gives most of its glamour shots
to Tom Cruise, playing an American who helps his Asian friends far
more than they help him. This follows a familiar Zwick pattern.
Glory cozied up to Matthew Broderick more than Denzel
Washington, even though its subject was black Civil War soldiers.
Mr. Zwick also seems convinced that his stories are so fascinating
that he can tell them very, very slowly. His greatest achievement
in this area is the 1994 historical romance Legends of the
Fall, in which you can almost see the characters' mustaches
grow, one tedious millimeter at a time." --David Sterritt,
The Christian Science Monitor

"As legend has it, the samurai of Japan were among the greatest
warriors in world history. As Hollywood has it, none was greater
than Tom Cruise
Cruise acts up a storm here, using at least
two facial expressions, but is upstaged by Watanabe, a Japanese
star with riveting screen presence." --Jack Mathews, The New
York Daily News
|