|
THE LADYKILLERS
A self-proclaimed professor
of linguistics who secretly indulges in a life of crime masterminds
a heist, but he and his gang may have to terminate his sweet old
landlady if she doesn't stop getting in the way.
CAST: Tom Hanks, Irma P. Hall, Marlon Wayans,
J.K. Simmons, Tzi Ma, Ryan Hurst, Greg Grunberg, George Wallace,
Jason Weaver
WRITER-DIRECTORS: Joel and Ethan Coen
"Hanks
tries his hand at a king-size heartless comic role, and flubs it
terribly. He looks slack and pasty and, what's worse, sounds slack
and pasty
When he recites Edgar Allan Poe to Hall and her fellow
widows and matrons, it's unbelievable and condescending to think
he razzle-dazzles them -- he turns ringing verse into white noise
Hanks
has siphoned all his energy into tics like a mirthless incisor-baring
laugh, and there's not much vitality left -- his eyes are bright
yet glassy, like cheap marbles
The Coen brothers dumb down
a classic character-built farce with gags about irritable bowel
syndrome and monophonic stereotypes who aren't even strong enough
to carry their gags to the finish line
This movie is much more
daring than the first film about using graphic elements like a dismembered
finger, and much less daring about toying with the naughtiness of
putting an airy character in peril." --Michael Sragow, Baltimore
Sun
"Giddy with the joy of playing, at long last, a bona fide villain,
Mr. Hanks swans through the role of G. H. Dorr, Ph.D., a supposed
professor of classics whose true vocation is crime, with a vaudevillian
relish that would be unseemly if it were not contagious
the
story is a flimsy frame to be ornamented with diverting bric-a-brac,
and the movie as a whole is something of a paradox: a work of elaborate
and painstaking craftsmanship that is at the same time a piece of
junk." --A.O. Scott, The New York Times
"This
is the most cartoonish, over-the-top character Hanks has played
since his Bosom Buddies/Bachelor Party days.
It is also his most intensely annoying. A lot of The Ladykillers
is like that: Irritating when it should be amusing, dumb when it
should be zany, flat when it should be snappy
The Ladykillers
sports an outstanding soundtrack of spirited gospel music. But as
a comedy, it's deadly." --Rene Rodriguez, Miami Herald
"Where Alexander Mackendricks film offered a delicately
diabolical blend of the ordinary and the brutal it was a
character comedy about a hilariously thwarted attempt to kill a
frail old woman the new Ladykillers bludgeons
you with cartoonish gags about stupid football players, irritable-bowel
syndrome and (for the second Coen film in a row) somebody accidentally
shooting himself in the head. For all their considerable talent,
the Coens have almost always had trouble telling stories, and here
they cram the whole biddy-bashing premise into the last few minutes,
where it lacks all menace and brio. Is it possible that these aficionados
of black comedy dont realize that The Ladykillers
is supposed to be one?" --John Powers, LA Weekly
"You have to look at the earlier film to understand where the
Coen brothers went wrong -- terribly, noisily, annoyingly wrong.
They've made a broad comedy out of a black comedy and completely
lost its charm in the process. The Coens' film has an interesting,
if not quite convincing, performance from Tom Hanks, a few good
laughs and some typically inspired camera work and production design.
Otherwise, it's just there, flopping around on the screen
The
black characters in the film are either dumb, lazy or arm-waving
Baptist spiritualists, and all are the butts of jokes. Not very
good jokes at that." --Jack Mathews, The New York Daily News
"Every black person, from the well-meaning widow to the chief
of police, is oblivious, ill-mannered, or both
it's insulting
when such savvy filmmakers expect us to laugh automatically at four-letter
words, bathroom humor, and caricatures as crude as they are unoriginal.
At its best, The Ladykillers soars above its own worst
instincts, especially when Hanks and Hall take over the action
it's
too bad the Coens have chosen to aim most of their humor below the
belt, not above the collar." --David Sterritt, The Christian
Science Monitor
"Although the movie never jells, its oddness keeps it from
being boring. Tom Hanks provides such an eccentric performance that
it's fun just to watch him behaving -- to listen to speeches that
coil through endless florid ornamentation. That the purpose of a
criminal in such a situation would be to become invisible -- as
Guinness, despite his bad teeth, tried to do in the 1955 film --
escapes the Coens
What the movie finally lacks, I think, is
modesty
Ladykillers is always wildly signaling
for us to notice it. Not content to be funny, it wants to be FUNNY!
" --Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times
"It gives the Coens a chance to stage some rousing gospel numbers
that have nothing to do with the plot, and Tom Hanks a chance to
ditch his socially-responsible-movie-star persona for a spell and
attempt a full-scale comic impersonation. He succeeds, by the waywith
gorgeous precision
The Ladykillers is small and
compactit doesn't kill, it's just a doodlebut it's a
very pleasant cartoon for grown-ups." --David Edelstein, Slate
"This is as far from Gump, the holy fool, as an actor can get.
And Hanks seizes the moment
Sadly, The Ladykillers
never lives up to its promise. In updating the 1955 British comedy
of the same name (with Alec Guinness as the professor), the Coens
turn the film into an academic exercise. It's as if the brothers
admired the Swiss-watch precision of the original and wanted to
take it apart to see how the pieces would work in a new setting.
As an experiment, it's fascinating. But damn if the fiddling doesn't
suck the life out of the laughs
you'll have to watch the original
film to see it done right." --Peter Travers, Rolling Stone
"The
Ladykillers, like other Coen brothers movies from Raising
Arizona to O Brother, Where Art Thou?, has a dark
and subversive sense of humor that may not be for everyone. And
the language sometimes reaches the Bad Santa level of
obscenity. But those who like Coen brothers movies -- and I love
them -- should find The Ladykillers to be among their
funniest and most memorable films. The acting, particularly by Hanks
and Hall (above), is delightful, and the gospel music that dominates
the soundtrack is exhilarating." -- Harper Barnes, St. Louis
Post-Dispatch
"One can't help but suspect that the actors considered this
film absolutely hilarious. But factor in the audience, and that
becomes a minority opinion
The film never settles into an assured
rhythm, and instead the actors always seem to be pushing, putting
the hard sell on an audience that, however distracted by the strenuousness
of the sales pitch, still isn't buying
the Coen brothers could
be blamed for all of this, and yet some movies aren't really anybody's
fault. Some movies just don't need to get made -- but the only way
to find out is to make them." --Mick LaSalle, San Francisco
Chronicle
"Ladykillers is a Southern-style Ocean's
11 without the pretty boys and Vegas attitude but with plenty
of laughs
Joel and Ethan Coen have fashioned a darkly funny
though not brilliant update of the original 1955 Ladykillers
Hall
plays her role with robust flair, and Marlon Wayans as the inside
man/janitor is a hoot. But it is Hanks' pitch-perfect timing and
eccentric portrayal that make the movie. You can't wait to hear
what sardonically archaic utterance comes out of his mouth next
Those
seeking a quirky and clever comedy should hightail it to The
Ladykillers forthwith." --Claudia Puig, USA Today
"Not quite top-drawer Coen Bros., but good enough to make you
wish it were, The Ladykillers is a case of being grateful
for small pleasures
The feeling of being not quite there pervades
the story, which unfortunately relies on such played-out humour
as toilet gags, usually the last resort of filmmakers who are a
lot less talented than the Coens." --Peter Howell, Toronto
Star
"The Coens are longtime masters of quirky characters and situations,
but even they can't generate any laughs from repeated jokes about
Garth's irritable bowel syndrome, which usually strikes at particularly
inopportune times. But the flick is worth sticking with for Hanks'
and Hall's superlative acting
Hall is more than a match for
Hanks--who risks going over the top in a role that may not be everyone's
cup of tea, but is a refreshing and daring change of pace for an
actor in danger of being typecast as Saint Tom for his
good-guy roles." --Lou Lumenick, The New York Post
|