|
HOLES
A no-nonsense prison warden and her two
yes-men force juvenile inmates to dig deep holes in the desert sands
of Texas because harsh discipline and back-breaking labor build
character. Besides, the warden happens to know something she shouldnt
about some buried treasure.
CAST: Sigourney Weaver, Jon Voight, Tim Blake
Nelson, Shia LaBeouf, Patricia Arquette, Henry Winkler, Eartha Kitt,
Nathan Davis, Khleo Thomas, Jake M. Smith, Byron Cotton
DIRECTOR: Andrew Davis
"Louis
Sachar's young adult novel Holes has become a literary
phenomenon because of how fervently its target audience has embraced
it. It's now been turned into a movie with the younger crowd in
mind, but older adults savvy enough to disregard labels will find
it surprisingly rewarding. Working from a screenplay by Sachar himself,
director Andrew Davis, best known for The Fugitive,
has come up with a sweetly entertaining fable about strange doings
in a juvenile correction facility in Texas that switches tones between
the comic and the menacing
Holes, as opposed to
many films about young people, neither preaches nor panders."
--Kenneth Turan, The Los Angeles Times
"
a movie so strange that it escapes entirely from the
family genre and moves into fantasy. Like Willy Wonka and
the Chocolate Factory, it has fearsome depths and secrets
Holes jumps the rails, leaves all expectations behind,
and tells a story that's not funny ha-ha but funny peculiar. I found
it original and intriguing
I walked in expecting a movie for
thirteensomethings, and walked out feeling challenged and satisfied.
Curious, how much more grown up and sophisticated Holes
is than Anger Management. --Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times
"Those who come to the movie cold will find it an exasperating
assembly of brutal pedantry and whimsies, boasting far less charm
or grace than even the first Harry Potter picture
the
way Louis Sachar has adapted his own novel and Andrew Davis has
directed it, the wacky subplots just spill out higgledy-piggledy
and land on your head
patience wears away as the film laboriously
fits each detail into a destiny that rewards the righteous and punishes
the villains
The comedy falls as limp as a snapless cartoon;
the melodrama lacks even the ersatz, industrial-grade excitement
of such Andrew Davis thrillers as The Fugitive."
--Michael Sragow, The Baltimore Sun
"The director, Andrew Davis (The Fugitive), has
turned the book's spare, gritty allegory into a shaggy-dog saga
that is sometimes hectic but always surprising and never easy, predictable
or false
The tough, prickly camaraderie among the boys and
their solidarity in the face of adult cruelty give the picture its
heart
The weaselly Mr. Nelson, the growly, strutting Mr. Voight
and the chilly, feline Ms. Weaver form a fine menagerie of grown-up
corruption
Mr. LaBeouf, with his soft face and curly hair,
rises to the challenge of depicting a coddled, sensitive young man
who must prove his toughness without sacrificing his decency
Yes,
Holes is certainly the thing that schoolchildren will
drag their parents to see on spring-break afternoons, but the parents
who are dragged will find themselves watching the best film released
by a major American studio so far this year." --A.O. Scott,
The New York Times
"You don't have to be a kid to dig Holes
Andrew Davis' very un-Disney-like Disney movie is a dense yarn with
a range of humor, imagination and emotions as wide as the desert
floor upon which it is set
It's a wonder that Disney is releasing
the film under its family banner. The movie has very scary moments
involving venomous creatures, an occult narrative thread, magic
realism, some blunt violence and a major subplot about an interracial
romance. We're a long way here from Song of the South.
But Holes is indeed a great family movie." --Jack
Mathews, The New York Daily News
"Though this Disney version was adapted by Louis Sachar himself,
it fails to be anything special. It makes passable preteen entertainment
but comes off as clunky and heavy-handed in most of the places it
should be graceful and enchanting
The plot points are predictable,
the characters seem impossibly broad, and the direction has no subtlety.
The whole thing plays like one more TV after-school special. Worse,
the film so concentrates on the non-stop cruelty suffered by the
young hero that it sends a morbid message. It all ends happily,
of course, but not before painting such an ugly view of the world
that its PG-rating seems highly questionable." --William Arnold,
The Seattle Post-Intelligencer
"Just when it seemed as if the Harry Potter tomes
were the only thing going in contemporary kid's fiction, Disney
has unearthed a treasure in Sachar's award-winning Holes,
a wholly original heroic comedy that maintains the courage of its
own screwy convictions
It's a fat, overstuffed bird of a plot,
but the messiness is part and parcel of the film's off-center appeal
Holes
is a wayward charmer." --Jan Stuart, Newsday
"
as bizarre a children's movie as Disney has ever made
Holes
suffers even more than the 'Harry Potter' films from a compulsion
to be faithful to the source material, including cramming in a head-spinning
assortment of characters and subplots
Holes clocks
in at nearly two hours. It's a long, slow slog through the desert,
best appreciated by fans of the book." --Lou Lumenick, The
New York Post
|