|
THE GOOD THIEF
An American gambler
who has sunk to shooting heroin in the mens room of a dive
in Nice is suddenly presented with the opportunity of shaping up
and pulling off a heist at a Monte Carlo casino.
CAST: Nick Nolte, Nutsa Kukhianidze, Ralph Fiennes, Tcheky Karyo,
Emir Kusturica, Jason Flemyng, Gerard Damon, Ouassini Embarek, Nino
Kukhanidze, Marc Lavoine, James Quatroch, Said Taghmanoui
DIRECTOR: Neil Jordan
"Nick
Nolte can be utterly convincing playing both dissolute wrecks who
pull out their rotting teeth (Affliction) and pomaded
captains of industry in black tie and tails from the world of Henry
James (The Golden Bowl). His characters are never clear-cut,
though: The wrecks have their existential graces, and the captains
are often clouded by regret. In Neil Jordans The Good
Thief, Nolte gets to play someone who is both a lowlife and
a natural-born aristocrat. And more than ever he makes it clear
how thin the dividing line is between the two
At times, The
Good Thief is like a fashion show of swank, outré imagery,
and all this froufrou slows down the pleasures of the heist
All
this dazzle would normally sink a movie of this kind, just as it
sank Oceans Eleven, but fortunately theres
also Noltes ravaged flamboyance. He may seem to lurch through
the landscape, but hes surprisingly light on his feet. This
actor is comfortable in his rough hide
Bob is a marvelous creationa
faker who is also the genuine article. Hes the perfect hero
for a movie about the world as one big scam." --Peter Rainer,
New York Magazine
"Whether he's staggering through the mean streets of Nice or
swaggering through the casinos of Monte Carlo, Nick Nolte is in
a great form as the garrulous Bob Montagnet, a gone-to-seed master
thief and compulsive gambler who rouses himself to attempt one last
heist in Neil Jordan's sensationally enjoyable neo-noir crime drama.
It's billed as a remake of Jean-Pierre Melville's classic Bob
le Flambeur, but it's really more of a jazzy-bluesy riff on
the 1955 film's hard-boiled romantic notions of grace under pressure
and honor among thieves." --Joe Leydon, The San Francisco Examiner
"Noltes grave performance combines a devil-may-care
attitude with existential blues
This dissolute yet charming
man reveals weakness and ambitionthe human traits that have
always animated Jordans storytelling
Most of all, The
Good Thief shows Jordans sympathy for human folly to
be generous, insightful, visionary. Hes not just repeating
genre; hes pursuing human truth. Working again with the great
cinematographer Chris Menges, Jordan reminds you how wondrous movies
can look
Its the first color noir movie I can think of
that rivals the emotional subtlety of black and white
The
Good Thief holds attention agreeably but its also just
plain dazzling to look at. At last! The movie year has been jumpstarted."
--Armond White, New York Press
"Promising as it seems in theory, everything in this new version,
like Lena Lamont's image in Singin' in the Rain, falls
apart as soon as the talking starts. The problem is unconvincingly
romanticized dialogue joined to artificial delivery. Everyone from
Nolte's Bob Montagnet on down can't help but trip over the film's
fake-hip, pleased-with-itself banter. It's a painfully artificial
world drowning in world-weary cynicism, where attitude easily wins
out over heroin as the hipster's drug of choice
The film overplays
its hand, self-consciously pushing artifice past the point of phoniness
Biggest
offender in this department is star Nolte, who's been encouraged
to blowzily overact in a way that is almost painful. With his trademark
whisky voice sounding close to whiny, Nolte's Bob affects a strained
casualness that couldn't be less convincing
this kind of puerile
romanticism doesn't do anybody any good." --Kenneth Turan,
The Los Angeles Times
"Oscar-winner Neil Jordan ('The Crying Game')
loads his smart, entertaining heist movie with sexual tension and
places it squarely on Nick Nolte's capable shoulders. The two-time
Oscar nominee delivers a shambling, sweet-natured performance as
Bob, an aging American gambler and thief living in Nice, France.
Inspired by the French crime classic Bob Le Flambeur, the thriller
involves Bob's plans for one last elaborate score while he tries
-- and fails -- to resist the advances of a much younger heroine
(hot gamine Nutsa Kukhianidze) and the allure of his old demon--heroin."
--Thelma Adams, US Weekly
"It's a triumph of flourish, all weathered, movie-star-size
gestures
By setting the picture on the impossibly gorgeous
Riviera and using shades of blue as visual metaphors, Mr. Jordan,
working with the cinematographer Chris Menges, makes the film's
look exemplary: it combines American flamboyance and French existentialist
delirium
Mr. Nolte uses The Good Thief as a haven
for a majestic ruin he has worked at for years. It's quite an accomplishment.
There aren't many American actors who have made a penchant for self-destructive
behavior blossom into a fully realized gallery of performances
The
movie is the ultimate caper, a work of brazen ebullience."
--Elvis Mitchell, The New York Times
"Neil Jordan's reinvention of Jean- Pierre Melville's 1955
chestnut Bob le Flambeur is a much more interesting
time-waster than was Stephen Soderbergh's Ocean's 11.
Retitled The Good Thief and retailored to the ravaged
glamour of Nick Nolte, this one is thick with seamy Riviera atmosphere,
seductive scoring from Frida Oscar-winner Elliot Goldenthal
and jazzy cinematography by Chris Menges that evokes the glory days
of French cinema's New Wave. It pulses with erudition and visual
kicks, but has the dulled impact of a time-sensitive bottled message
that has washed ashore years too late to be of any practical use
The
crime itself lacks the deftness of the great heist movies, in part
because the actors are never as colorful as the writing wants them
to be. The biggest culprits are the two respiration-challenged romantic
leads: Nolte heaves every line as if its his last, while the sullenly
nasal Kukhianidze sounds like a ventriloquist is throwing his voice
through her nose. While we're on the subject, has anyone else had
it with beautiful young women flinging themselves at dissipating
male movie stars, or is it just me?" --Jan Stuart, Newsday
"Nick Nolte's DWI arrest may have been fodder for Steve Martin's
monologue at the Oscars--but the troubled actor is at the absolute
top of his game in Neil Jordan's The Good Thief, a casino
heist movie so smooth and satisfying it makes the similar Ocean's
Eleven look like a game of three-card monte
Though the
setup is familiar in an overworked genre, Jordan pulls it off effortlessly--it's
easily his best directing job since The Crying Game
it's a special triumph for Nolte, a magnificent ruin of a
man who jabbers nonstop in a rumbling bass and sports one of the
worst dye jobs this side of Miami Beach--making Jack Nicholson in
About Schmidt look positively vain by comparison
the
year's first must-see movie." --Lou Lumenick, The New York
Post
"With his haggard good looks and bearish presence, Nolte is
the main event in this colorful three-ring circus of a heist picture
Jordan has made movies in many genres and styles, but seems most
comfortable in the demimondes of Mona Lisa and The
Crying Game -- in other words, among men like Bob, who follow
their hearts even up blind alleys, trusting in luck all the way."
--Jami Bernard, The New York Daily News
|