|
DE-LOVELY
Cole Porter, surely one of the most urbane
Americans to have been born and bred in Indiana, married a chic
New York socialite and lived gaily, if grimly, ever after.
CAST: Kevin Kline, Ashley Judd, Jonathan
Pryce, Kevin McNally, Allan Corduner, Sandra Nelson, Kieth Allen,
James Wilby, Kevin McKidd, Peter Polycarpou, Richard Dillane, Edward
Baker-Duly, Elvis Costello, Natalie Cole, Sheryl Crow, Mick Hucknall,
Alanis Morissette, Diana Krall, Robbie Williams, Caroline OConnor
DIRECTOR: Irwin Winkler
SCREENWRITER: Jay Cocks
"Director
Irwin Winkler and screenwriter Jay Cocks focus on the homosexual
Porter's marriage to socialite Linda Lee. But they squander the
potential of such an intriguing relationship by depicting the glamorous
couple as frivolous gadabouts with the hearts and souls of ice sculptures.
Porter is portrayed by Oscar-winner Kevin Kline without subtlety;
he's so changelessly happy-go-lucky even while breaking Linda's
heart that he seems merely shallow and self-centered. Linda
(Ashley Judd, taking a break from cop thrillers) puts up with her
husband's homosexual flings presumably because he's just
so darned charming weeps silently and smokes a lot...The
songs are plonked down according to how their lyrics fit a scene,
rather than being arranged to make any chronological sense."
--Megan Lehmann, The New York Post
"Lethally inert
a movie so lifeless and drained of genuine
joie de vivre it makes you long for the largely fictional earlier
film
Night and Day at least had a sense of style.
It may be factually absurd, but it glides along like a Porter song
Watching
De-Lovely, which unfolds as a bumpy, muddled This
Is Your Life series of confusing, overcrowded tableaus, you
have the creepy sense of watching adult children (with the singular
exception of Mr. Kline, who can surmount any disaster) dressed up
in period costume at a school pageant. Ms. Judd's performance, in
particular, is clueless as to style." --Stephen Holden, The
New York Times
"The movie is remarkably touching and engrossing, with Kline's
spot-on acting and realistically second-rate singing balancing Judd's
one-note performance as his wife. It's too bad Jay Cocks's screenplay
spends far too long winding Porter's story up, but overall the tuneful
comedy-drama is every bit as de-lovely as its title promises."
--David Sterritt, The Christian Science Monitor
"De-Lovely is openly gay and overwhelmingly glum
The
disconnect is particularly acute when Winkler begins evoking '20s
sophistication with anachronistic interpolations from the 1956 movie
High Society
Winkler takes care to quote the famously
bad 1946 Cole Porter story, Night and Day, but if that
was a minor tragedy, his remake is closer to unfunny farce."
--J. Hoberman, The Village Voice
"Kevin Kline does a fine job portraying Porter as he's written.
But the script is missing much of the complexity and some of the
humanity of the composer, one of the greats of the 20th century.
De-Lovely is primarily about Porter's extraordinary
relationship with his wife, Linda Lee Porter, played by Ashley Judd
in one of her best roles since her debut in 1993's Ruby in
Paradise
Viewers might be put off by Kline's efforts
to sing as Cole Porter
in his quest for authenticity, he uses
a voice that might grate on audiences." --Claudia Puig, USA
Today
"Whats
missing from this dreary, tin-eared fiasco is any sense of the genius
and humanity of Porter himself. No heart, no soul, no brains, no
fun
As Linda, Ashley Judd is scarily inept, a giggly, beaming
helpmate who copes with every crisis by lighting up another cigarette.
Kevin Kline seems basically uncomfortable as the boy from Indiana
who discovers he likes boys from Indiana and practically everywhere
else in the world. His Porter lacks warmth, humor, compassion and
dignity. Maybe the man who turned out Anything Goes
and Kiss Me Kate really was an irresponsible narcissist.
If so, why bother to tell his story--why not just listen to his
music?" --Guy Flatley,
Moviecrazed
"You enter a movie with that title, prepared to be enchanted.
You struggle out a couple of hours later, lost in a fog of gloom.
For this films makers grimly insist that the songwriters
life was essentially a betrayal of his impeccably sophisticated
art when they might have more profitbly seen his work as a gallant
triumph over the difficulties of a messy life
Kline suggests
Porters intractable snootiness but none of his perpetually
boyish elan. Judd mostly simpers." --Richard Schickel, Time
Magazine
"There are terrific performances from Kline and Judd, some
breathtaking staging and production design, and, of course, some
of the best music and lyrics of the 20th century
De-Lovely
is night and day over Night and Day
Winkler neither
avoids nor exploits the composer's homosexuality. It's always present,
but the film's focus is on the strangely powerful bond that held
the Porters' sexless marriage together for more than 30 years."
--Jack Mathews, The New York Daily News
"De-Lovely is effervescent, in the manner of a
cold-cuts platter that never made it out of the car at the beach
picnic. Under the plastic bubble, it's generating gas
Judd
is a one-woman lumber yard, beautiful and smug, with a face frozen
in a sanctimonious smirk. Her selfrighteous nobility makes Linda
Cole into a martyr of heterosexuality, which itself skews the supposed
morality of the movie
The intricacies of the Porter
marriage, central to screenwriter Jay Cocks' witheringly stupid
script, share the screen with an album's worth of musical performances,
which will be touted by many as the movie's saving grace. Unfortunately,
Winkler here, too, shows a tin ear
De-Lovely just
seems de-ranged." --John Anderson, Newsday
"From all accounts, Cole Porter did have fun.
He was also sly and witty and the essence of style, and 'De-Lovely'
is none of these things. The usually blithe, exuberant Kline seems
at a loss here...Judd is worse. Swanning around in Armani, her eyes
lustrous with empathy, her smile bright and fixed, she does almost
nothing during the entire film but smoke...Such glorious Porter
classics as 'What Is This Thing Called Love?,' 'Night and Day,'
'Begin the Beguine' and 'Love for Sale' are performed by pop stars
like Sheryl Crowe, Elvis Costello and Alanis Morissette. The results
are not happy... Its not until the end of the film, when you
hear the real Cole Portersexy, elegant, full of mischief,
doing 'Youre the Top'-- that you start smiling." --Diane
Baroni, Moviecrazed
"
a likable but plodding blend of
strenuous style and canned psychology
Winkler doesnt
skimp on Porters subterranean gay life, but his approach is
polite and gingerly, as if hes holding his nose
Winkler
never ventures any truly muscular speculation about the glue that
held together the partnership between a man who gallantly stepped
up to try for the baby his wife longed for yet kept her waiting
night and day while he dallied with beautiful boys, and a woman
so devoted (or controlling) that she ended up as his procurer
as
a portrait of an unusual marriage its de-lumbering, de-liberate
and de-cidedly flat." --Ella Taylor, LA Weekly
"Marred by a decorum more appropriate to some of the old MGM
musicals Porter worked on, as well as dialogue so clunky it surely
would have distressed the clever lyricist's ears, De-Lovely
is too flatly refined to evoke the turbulent existence it examines
Kline
gives one of his standard, sensitive-yet-not-very-cutting acting
jobs." --Bob Strauss, L.A. Daily News
"Kevin
Kline catches, without appearing to try, that blissful, tart mix
of sophistication and gaiety (in both senses) that marked the real
Porter
Despite its frankness and many resources, De-Lovely's
lavish bio has a slightly hollow ring
Cocks' script is sketchy
and the movie itself not the sip of cinematic champagne we'd like
it to be
The name Cole Porter remains a kind of a passkey to
a vanished world of wit, elegance, irony and pop sensuality, and
I only wish the movie had unlocked more doors, opened up more of
that world." --Michael Wilmington, Chicago Tribune
|