|
21 GRAMS
A recent recipient
of a heart transplant, a grief-shattered widow and an intensely
religious ex-con make incendiary contact.
CAST: Sean Penn, Benicio Del Toro, Naomi Watts, Melissa Leo, Charlotte
Gainsbourg, Danny Huston, Clea DuVall, Marc Musso, David Chattam,
Teresa Delgado, Stephen Bridgewate, Kevin Chapman
DIRECTOR: Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu
"21
Grams" is a ruminative, stunned look at life after deaththat
is, the existence of the living after they have been devastated
by loss; it's the aftermath
Sean Penn, Benicio Del Toro and
Naomi Watts achieve something that doesn't sound as if it's possible:
a virtuosity in the depiction of people wasting away minute by minute.
Be prepared for it. You won't come out unaffected, because the depths
of intimacy that the Mexican director Alejandro González
Iñárritu plumbs here are so rarely touched by filmmakers
that 21 Grams is tantamount to the discovery of a new
country." --Elvis Mitchell, The New York Times
"
the
kind of bad movie that makes a reviewer feel terrible. It has been
put together with great sincerity, and yet, impassioned and affecting
as some of it is, 21 Grams is also an arrogant failure
Through
most of the movie, we dont know where we are in the story
or why a given action should matter
but, scene after scene,
its breathtakingly acted and as painfully soulful as a meeting
of recovering alcoholics
the revelation of the movie is Naomi
Watts, who goes from glum silence to violently spasmodic outbursts
without hitting a false note." --David Denby, The New Yorker
"Under its seemingly chic despair, its celebration of squalor
and pain, its violence, its willfully skewed narrative scheme, 21
Grams turns out to be a powerful relic from a bygone age:
It's really a miracle of faith movie
It argues
that, yes, God has a plan, clever and meaningful, and that coded
in all human actions are messages from above
It has so many
Big Emotional Moments, so many tears are shed, so many screams are
screamed, that it's almost, but not quite, funny
We flash forward
and backward in time--you must be patient--as we basically come
to understand the before, the during and the after of the intersection
of these three lives and what it comes to
the movie itself
is a miracle: tough, smart, relentless, provocative and, above all,
serious." --Stephen Hunter, The Washington Post
"Having butchered grown-ups and dogs in his debut feature,
Amores Perros, the Mexican director Alejandro González
Iñárritu now turns his attention to little girls,
whose senseless deaths (along with that of their father) form the
centerpiece of 21 Grams
The movie leaps backward,
then forward, then sideways, then does a back-flip, then executes
a handstand followed by a half-twist double-gainer
Is the strategy
to make you work so hard to determine where you are in the timeline
that you overlook what a dreary and conventional little soap opera
this is?
Iñárritu keeps returning to the dad
and his two little girls as they hurry down the sidewalk toward
their fate, circling closer and closer to the horrifying momentan
art-house sicko's striptease." --David Edelstein, Slate
"Unlike
Memento, the reverse-told thriller to which it is being
compared, 21 Grams is highly stylized without being
a stunt
Iñárritu takes his complex tale of hope
and redemption and breaks it into a mosaic of emotional tiles that
add up to more than the whole
by forcing us to concentrate
on each piece of the puzzle, Iñárritu and screenwriter
Guillermo Arriaga heighten our connection to and empathy with their
deeply wounded characters. Penn's understated performance as a man
who doesn't believe he deserves to be alive may be his best. But
the real heartbreakers here are Watts, emotionally raw as a woman
seeking revenge for her loss, and Del Toro, as a man turning against
himself and the faith he believes both saved and abandoned him."
Jack Mathews, --The New York Daily News
"21 Grams unstintingly explores and exposes excruciating
pain, raw grief, ruinous vengeance and life-affirming resilience,
creating human portraits that are uncommonly exhilarating in their
honesty. This is cinematic art in its highest form
Like Mystic
River, its portrayal of grim experiences can be hard to sit
through. But, also like Mystic River, its performances
are so riveting they make the movie well worth the discomfort.The
two movies share the same star, Sean Penn, whose extraordinary performance
in both affirms his status as one of the best actors of his generation.
Naomi Watts fulfills the promise she showed in Mulholland Drive
and gives the most heart-wrenching performance of any actress so
far this year. Filling out the film's starring troika is Benicio
Del Toro, who hasn't been this good since his Oscar-winning turn
in Traffic." --Claudia Puig, USA Today
"Its forceful, to be sure, but in a lurid way that suggests
a telenovela thats been baking in the sun too long
21
Grams sputters out in a farrago of flashbacks and flashforwards
and flashinbetweens. The one signal achievement is Del Toros
performance, which is ferocious and hearty. No transplant needed
here." --Peter Rainer, New York Magazine
"In raw, charged images and superbly acted scenes, Iñárritu
and his Amores Perros screenwriter, Guillermo Arriaga,
craft another compelling drama of fate and death, love and betrayal
Blessed
with one of the strongest casts of any American movie this year,
this bravura film, with its radical structure, is full of risk and
reward. Its fiery narrative keeps driving us toward doom--and the
odd pleasure and pain of watching lives and limits suddenly, unpredictably
explode." Michael Wilmington, Chicago Tribune
"Where Amores Perros was a feast of energy, wit
and imagination, 21 Grams is like a starvation diet
a movie that wallows so profoundly in its own misery that
watching it is like atoning for some sin you didnt commit.
How much suffering is enough suffering? For the characters of 21
Grams, suffering is all there is; theyre martyrs in
training
once you peel away all the nonlinear editing, bleached-out
cinematography and vehicular manslaughter thats been retained,
however superficially, from their earlier collaboration, youre
left with a movie so self-flagellatingly ascetic that suddenly Ordinary
People starts to look like a movie you can go to for a raucous
chuckle." --Scott Foundas, LA Weekly
"21 Grams is a grim, compelling and exceedingly
well-acted meditation on life, death, guilt and redemption
Penn,
del Toro and Watts create some of the year's richest, most wrenching
characters
a rare Hollywood product depicting class differences
with any kind of honesty. The title refers to the weight--perhaps
the soul--the body is said to lose at the precise moment of death.
But 21 Grams has no shortage of soul, wit or intelligence.
It's terrific." --Lou Lumenick, The New York Post
"The
humanist aspirations and attention-grabbing, time-altering structure
of Mexican director Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu and his writer,
Guillermo Arriaga, can't make up for the fact that their movie is
sprayed with an aerosol of grandeur to cover up the odor of pulp
Despite
this, the acting is something to see. After Penn's operatic, wildly
overpraised bombast in Mystic River, his relative smallness
here is a mercy. As for Watts, when she's not crying and screaming,
she screams and cries. It's the sort of ferocious stuff that makes
Oscar voting easy for some people. Still, the role is a couple of
breakdowns in search of a character. Del Toro does the truly eloquent
work here, making rage, pathos, passiveness, and remorse more than
a series of Oscar clips." --Wesley Morris, Boston Globe
"In this film, everything has already happened, and it's as
if God, or the director, is shuffling the deck after the game is
over
By fracturing his chronology, Inarritu isolates key moments
in the lives of his characters, so that they have to stand alone.
There is a point at which this stops being a strategy and starts
being a stunt
21 Grams tells such a tormenting
story, however, that it just about survives its style. It would
have been more powerful in chronological order, and even as a puzzle,
it has a deep effect
acting does not get much better than
the work done here by Penn, Del Toro and Watts." --Roger Ebert,
Chicago Sun-Times
"21 Grams is as much jigsaw puzzle as movie. This
fractured soap opera demands an active viewer. The soundtrack hiss
at the New York Film Festival press screening was the whisper of
people explaining it to each other
Iñárritu ruminates
upon the mystery of life. Accident or divine plan?
The movie's
dubious philosophical treatise draws conviction from its high-powered
cast
Watts, who has the most difficult scenes, is splendidly
mercurial; what's surprising is that those professional storm clouds
Penn and Del Toro are here as powerfully restrained as she is electrifying
21
Grams is a sad puzzle, but then, so is life." --J. Hoberman,
The Village Voice
"Inarritu and Arriaga have constructed their movie like a jigsaw
puzzle, or the broken shards of a pot that has to be pieced together
and made whole again. Chronology is tossed to the winds; the viewer
has to guess whether hes in the present, past or future
The
fragmented form adds to the anxiety and dread that hangs over 21
Grams, keeping us unsettled, uncertain and alert for danger
Once the pieces have fallen into place, it may strike you that the
peek-a-boo narrative strategy has been disguising a melodrama that,
in the plain light of day, looks more than a little overwrought."
--David Ansen, Newsweek
|